CAIE P1 2024 November — Question 8 10 marks

Exam BoardCAIE
ModuleP1 (Pure Mathematics 1)
Year2024
SessionNovember
Marks10
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicCircles
TypeNormal to circle at point
DifficultyModerate -0.3 This is a slightly below-average A-level question. Part (a) is routine completing the square (standard textbook exercise). Parts (b)(i-ii) require understanding that the normal passes through the center and using the tangent condition, but follow predictable steps with no novel insight needed. The 10 marks reflect length rather than conceptual difficulty.
Spec1.03b Straight lines: parallel and perpendicular relationships1.03d Circles: equation (x-a)^2+(y-b)^2=r^21.03e Complete the square: find centre and radius of circle1.03f Circle properties: angles, chords, tangents

The equation of a circle is \(x^2 + y^2 + px + 2y + q = 0\), where \(p\) and \(q\) are constants.
  1. Express the equation in the form \((x - a)^2 + (y - b)^2 = r^2\), where \(a\) is to be given in terms of \(p\) and \(r^2\) is to be given in terms of \(p\) and \(q\). [2]
The line with equation \(x + 2y = 10\) is the tangent to the circle at the point \(A(4, 3)\).
    1. Find the equation of the normal to the circle at the point \(A\). [3]
    2. Find the values of \(p\) and \(q\). [5]

Question 8:

AnswerMarks
8(a)2
  1   (y−(−1))2
 x− − p   + OE
AnswerMarks Guidance
  2 B1* 1  1 
Allow a=− p and b=−1,or centre is − p,−1.
2  2 
  1   2 (y−(−1))2  1  2
 x− − p   + =−q+1+ − P  OE
AnswerMarks
  2   2 DB1
2

AnswerMarks
8(b)(i)1
[Gradient of tangent =] −
AnswerMarks Guidance
2B1 OE
SOI
AnswerMarks Guidance
[Gradient of normal =] 2M1 Use of m m = −1with their numeric tangent gradient.
1 2
y−3
=2 y=2x−5 
AnswerMarks Guidance
x−4A1 OE
ISW
Allowy=2x+c, 3=24+c  c=−5.
3
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks

AnswerMarks
8(b)(ii)Method 1 for the first two marks:
 1 
−1−3=2− p−4 or −1=−p−5
AnswerMarks Guidance
 2 M1*  p 
Using their stated centre or  , 1 in their equation of the
 2 
normal.
AnswerMarks
p=−4A1
Method 2 for the first two marks:
1
−1=2x−5  x=2  − p=2
AnswerMarks Guidance
2M1* Using their normal equation and their stated centre or
 p 
 , 1.
 2 
AnswerMarks
p=−4A1
Method 3 for the first two marks:
dy dy  dy
2x+2y + p+2 =0  p=−8−8
 
AnswerMarks
dx dx  dxM1*
dy 1 
=−  p=−4
 
AnswerMarks Guidance
dx 2 A1
QuestionAnswer Marks
8(b)(ii)Method 1 for the last 3 marks:
r2 =(4−2)2 + ( 3−(−1))2 =20 M1* their p 
Using (4, 3) and their centre or  , 1 to find r2 or r.
 2 
1
−q+1+ p2 =20
AnswerMarks Guidance
4DM1 OE
Using their expression for r2 (from (a)) equated to their 20.
AnswerMarks
q=−15A1
Method 2 for the last 3 marks:
2−2−10  10
r= =
 
AnswerMarks Guidance
5  5M1* Using (2,−1) and x+2y−10=0 (distance from a point to a
line).
2
1 10 
−q+1+ p2 =
 
AnswerMarks Guidance
4  5DM1 OE
2
10 
Using their expression for r2 equated to their   .
 5
AnswerMarks
q=−15A1
Method 3 for the last 3 marks:
42 +32 +4p+6+q=0  4p+q+31=0 
OR
 4−   − 1 p     2 + ( 3−(−1))2 =−q+1+   − 1 p   2
AnswerMarks Guidance
  2   2 M1* (4,3)
Substituting into their circle equation.
AnswerMarks Guidance
4(−4)+q+31=0DM1 Substituting their p=−4.
q=−15A1
QuestionAnswer Marks
8(b)(ii)Alternative Method for Question 8(b)(ii)
42 +32 +4p+6+q=0
x2 +(2x−5)2+ px+2(2x−5)+q=0 with x=4
10−x 2 10−x
x2 +  + px+2 +q=0 with x=4
 2   2 
 y+5 2  y+5
  + y2 + p  +2y+q=0 with y=3
 2   2 
(10−2y)2 +y2 + p(10−2y)+2y+q=0 with y=3
AnswerMarks Guidance
Each of these  4p+q+31=0M1* Substituting (4,3) into their circle equation, or
replacing y with 2x−5 from the normal equation, or
10−x
replacing y with from the tangent equation, or
2
y+5
replacing x with from the normal equation, or
2
replacing x with10−2y from the tangent equation, and using
either x=4 or y=3to form an equation in p and q.
5 5
x2 +(p−6)x+35+q=0  (p−6)2 −4 (35+q) = 0
4 4
OR
5y2−y(38+2p)+100+10p+q=0  (38+2p)2−45(100+10p+q)=0
AnswerMarks Guidance
 Each of these p2 −12p−139−5q=0 M1* Solving the tangent and circle equations simultaneously to form
a quadratic equation in either x or y.
Then usingb2 −4ac=0 on their quadratic to form an equation
in p and q.
AnswerMarks
Solving the equations simultaneously to find p or qDM1
p=−4A1
q=−15A1
5
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks
Question 8:
--- 8(a) ---
8(a) | 2
  1   (y−(−1))2
 x− − p   + OE
  2  | B1* | 1  1 
Allow a=− p and b=−1,or centre is − p,−1.
2  2 
  1   2 (y−(−1))2  1  2
 x− − p   + =−q+1+ − P  OE
  2   2  | DB1
2
--- 8(b)(i) ---
8(b)(i) | 1
[Gradient of tangent =] −
2 | B1 | OE
SOI
[Gradient of normal =] 2 | M1 | Use of m m = −1with their numeric tangent gradient.
1 2
y−3
=2 y=2x−5 
x−4 | A1 | OE
ISW
Allowy=2x+c, 3=24+c  c=−5.
3
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
--- 8(b)(ii) ---
8(b)(ii) | Method 1 for the first two marks:
 1 
−1−3=2− p−4 or −1=−p−5
 2  | M1* |  p 
Using their stated centre or  , 1 in their equation of the
 2 
normal.
p=−4 | A1
Method 2 for the first two marks:
1
−1=2x−5  x=2  − p=2
2 | M1* | Using their normal equation and their stated centre or
 p 
 , 1.
 2 
p=−4 | A1
Method 3 for the first two marks:
dy dy  dy
2x+2y + p+2 =0  p=−8−8
 
dx dx  dx | M1*
dy 1 
=−  p=−4
 
dx 2  | A1
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
8(b)(ii) | Method 1 for the last 3 marks:
r2 =(4−2)2 + ( 3−(−1))2 =20  | M1* | their p 
Using (4, 3) and their centre or  , 1 to find r2 or r.
 2 
1
−q+1+ p2 =20
4 | DM1 | OE
Using their expression for r2 (from (a)) equated to their 20.
q=−15 | A1
Method 2 for the last 3 marks:
2−2−10  10
r= =
 
5  5 | M1* | Using (2,−1) and x+2y−10=0 (distance from a point to a
line).
2
1 10 
−q+1+ p2 =
 
4  5 | DM1 | OE
2
10 
Using their expression for r2 equated to their   .
 5
q=−15 | A1
Method 3 for the last 3 marks:
42 +32 +4p+6+q=0  4p+q+31=0 
OR
 4−   − 1 p     2 + ( 3−(−1))2 =−q+1+   − 1 p   2
  2   2  | M1* | (4,3)
Substituting into their circle equation.
4(−4)+q+31=0 | DM1 | Substituting their p=−4.
q=−15 | A1
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
8(b)(ii) | Alternative Method for Question 8(b)(ii)
42 +32 +4p+6+q=0
x2 +(2x−5)2+ px+2(2x−5)+q=0 with x=4
10−x 2 10−x
x2 +  + px+2 +q=0 with x=4
 2   2 
 y+5 2  y+5
  + y2 + p  +2y+q=0 with y=3
 2   2 
(10−2y)2 +y2 + p(10−2y)+2y+q=0 with y=3
Each of these  4p+q+31=0 | M1* | Substituting (4,3) into their circle equation, or
replacing y with 2x−5 from the normal equation, or
10−x
replacing y with from the tangent equation, or
2
y+5
replacing x with from the normal equation, or
2
replacing x with10−2y from the tangent equation, and using
either x=4 or y=3to form an equation in p and q.
5 5
x2 +(p−6)x+35+q=0  (p−6)2 −4 (35+q) = 0
4 4
OR
5y2−y(38+2p)+100+10p+q=0  (38+2p)2−45(100+10p+q)=0
 Each of these p2 −12p−139−5q=0  | M1* | Solving the tangent and circle equations simultaneously to form
a quadratic equation in either x or y.
Then usingb2 −4ac=0 on their quadratic to form an equation
in p and q.
Solving the equations simultaneously to find p or q | DM1
p=−4 | A1
q=−15 | A1
5
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
The equation of a circle is $x^2 + y^2 + px + 2y + q = 0$, where $p$ and $q$ are constants.

\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\item Express the equation in the form $(x - a)^2 + (y - b)^2 = r^2$, where $a$ is to be given in terms of $p$ and $r^2$ is to be given in terms of $p$ and $q$. [2]
\end{enumerate}

The line with equation $x + 2y = 10$ is the tangent to the circle at the point $A(4, 3)$.

\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\setcounter{enumi}{1}
\item \begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]
\item Find the equation of the normal to the circle at the point $A$. [3]
\item Find the values of $p$ and $q$. [5]
\end{enumerate}
\end{enumerate}

\hfill \mbox{\textit{CAIE P1 2024 Q8 [10]}}