Edexcel D1 2018 June — Question 1 10 marks

Exam BoardEdexcel
ModuleD1 (Decision Mathematics 1)
Year2018
SessionJune
Marks10
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicSorting Algorithms
TypeBinary Search Execution
DifficultyEasy -1.3 This question tests basic recall and mechanical application of standard D1 algorithms. Part (a) requires recognizing that binary search needs a sorted list (trivial). Part (b) is a routine bubble/quick sort execution showing iterations. Part (c) is straightforward binary search execution with middle-point calculations. Part (d) uses the formula log₂(n), a standard result. No problem-solving or novel insight required—purely algorithmic execution of textbook procedures.
Spec7.03a Algorithm definition: input, output, deterministic, finite7.03c Working with algorithms: trace, interpret, adapt7.03j Sorting: bubble sort and shuttle sort

1. $$\begin{aligned} & \text { Kerry (K) } \\ & \text { Nikki (N) } \\ & \text { Violet (V) } \\ & \text { Dev (D) } \\ & \text { Henri (H) } \\ & \text { Leslie (L) } \\ & \text { Enlai (E) } \\ & \text { Sylvester (S) } \\ & \text { Joan (J) } \end{aligned}$$ A binary search is to be performed on the names in the list above to locate the name Leslie.
  1. Explain why a binary search cannot be performed with the list in its present form.
  2. Using an appropriate algorithm, alter the list so that a binary search can be performed. You should state the name of the algorithm you use and show the list after each complete iteration.
  3. Use the binary search algorithm to locate the name Leslie in the altered list you obtained in (b). You must make your method clear. The binary search algorithm is to be used to search for a name in an alphabetical list of 727 names.
  4. Find the maximum number of iterations needed. You should justify your answer.

Question 1:
Part (a)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
The list is not in alphabetical orderB1 (1) CAO – must explicitly mention list is not in alphabetical order; just stating "not in order" is B0, but give B1 bod for "not in A-Z order"
Part (b)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
Quick sort demonstrated with pivot chosen (middle left or right)M1 Choosing first/last item as pivot is M0; first pass gives \(p\)
First pass correct AND next pivot(s) chosen correctly for second passA1 Second pass does not need to be correct
Second and third passes correct (follow through from first pass)A1ft No need to choose pivot for fourth pass
Sort complete, named correctlyA1 (4) CSO – all previous marks must have been awarded; "sort complete" statement required or final sorted list shown
Part (c)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
Pivot \(1 = \left\lfloor\frac{1+9}{2}\right\rfloor = 5\), Kerry, reject \(1-5\)M1 Mark pivot values only; allow restart from incorrect sorted list if correct (or implied) in (d)
Pivot \(2 = \left\lfloor\frac{6+9}{2}\right\rfloor = 8\), Sylvester, reject \(8-9\)A1 If K is not first pivot then M0
Pivot \(3 = \left\lfloor\frac{6+7}{2}\right\rfloor = 7\), Nikki, reject \(7\)A1 (3)
Pivot \(4 = 6\), Leslie – name found CSO – accept "found", "located", "stop" etc.; must be convinced Leslie has been located
Part (d)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
e.g. \(\log_2 727 = 9.505\ldots\) so \(10\) or maximum number of items in each passM1
e.g. \(727, 363, 181, 90, 45, 22, 11, 5, 2, 1\) so \(10\) iterationsA1 (2)
Total: 10 marks
Question 1 (Part d):
Iterative approach (values at start of each iteration):
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
At least 727, 363, 181, 90, … or embedded in calculation e.g. \([727+1]/2 = 364\), \([363+1]/2 = 182\), \([181+1]/2 = 91\), \([90+1]/2 = …\)M1
727, 363, 181, 90, 45, 22, 11, 5, 2, 1 so 10 iterationsA1
Iterative approach (values at end of each iteration):
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
At least 363, 181, 90, …M1
363, 181, 90, 45, 22, 11, 5, 2, 1 so 10 iterations (so 9 iterations is A0)A1
Other numerical arguments:
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMark Guidance
\(2^n > 727\), taking logs of both sides and solving for \(n\) (accept \(2^n = 727\)) OR stating \(n = 9.5058…\)M1 Answer given correct to 1 decimal place
Above with \(n = 10\) (no errors if calculation seen)A1 Allow recovery from equals
\(2^n > 727\) then state \(n = 10\) with no working unless \(2^9\) also consideredM1 only
\(\log_2 727 = …\)M1
\(… = 9.505…\) and hence 10A1 Answer given correctly to 1 dp
\(\frac{727}{2^n}\) considered with \(n=10\) is M1, showing explicitly that \(n=10\) is first value giving less than 1; \(\frac{727}{1024}\) or \(0.7099…\) must be seenM1, A1 Not sufficient to just say \(\frac{727}{2^{10}}\) is less than 1
Halving 727 ten times gives value less than or equal to 1, showing \(0.70996…\) correct to 1 d.p.M1, A1 Accept \(= 1\) as halving/dividing by 2 context
Answer of 10 with no workingM0
# Question 1:

## Part (a)

| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| The list is not in alphabetical order | B1 **(1)** | CAO – must explicitly mention list is not in alphabetical order; just stating "not in order" is B0, but give B1 bod for "not in A-Z order" |

## Part (b)

| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| Quick sort demonstrated with pivot chosen (middle left or right) | M1 | Choosing first/last item as pivot is M0; first pass gives $<p, p, >p$ |
| First pass correct AND next pivot(s) chosen correctly for second pass | A1 | Second pass does not need to be correct |
| Second and third passes correct (follow through from first pass) | A1ft | No need to choose pivot for fourth pass |
| Sort complete, **named correctly** | A1 **(4)** | CSO – all previous marks must have been awarded; "sort complete" statement required or final sorted list shown |

## Part (c)

| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| Pivot $1 = \left\lfloor\frac{1+9}{2}\right\rfloor = 5$, Kerry, reject $1-5$ | M1 | Mark pivot values only; allow restart from incorrect sorted list if correct (or implied) in (d) |
| Pivot $2 = \left\lfloor\frac{6+9}{2}\right\rfloor = 8$, Sylvester, reject $8-9$ | A1 | If K is not first pivot then M0 |
| Pivot $3 = \left\lfloor\frac{6+7}{2}\right\rfloor = 7$, Nikki, reject $7$ | A1 **(3)** | |
| Pivot $4 = 6$, Leslie – name found | | CSO – accept "found", "located", "stop" etc.; must be convinced Leslie has been located |

## Part (d)

| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| e.g. $\log_2 727 = 9.505\ldots$ so $10$ or maximum number of items in each pass | M1 | |
| e.g. $727, 363, 181, 90, 45, 22, 11, 5, 2, 1$ so $10$ iterations | A1 **(2)** | |

**Total: 10 marks**

# Question 1 (Part d):

## Iterative approach (values at start of each iteration):
| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| At least 727, 363, 181, 90, … or embedded in calculation e.g. $[727+1]/2 = 364$, $[363+1]/2 = 182$, $[181+1]/2 = 91$, $[90+1]/2 = …$ | M1 | |
| 727, 363, 181, 90, 45, 22, 11, 5, 2, 1 so 10 iterations | A1 | |

## Iterative approach (values at end of each iteration):
| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| At least 363, 181, 90, … | M1 | |
| 363, 181, 90, 45, 22, 11, 5, 2, 1 so 10 iterations (so 9 iterations is A0) | A1 | |

## Other numerical arguments:
| Answer | Mark | Guidance |
|--------|------|----------|
| $2^n > 727$, taking logs of both sides and solving for $n$ (accept $2^n = 727$) OR stating $n = 9.5058…$ | M1 | Answer given correct to 1 decimal place |
| Above with $n = 10$ (no errors if calculation seen) | A1 | Allow recovery from equals |
| $2^n > 727$ then state $n = 10$ with no working unless $2^9$ also considered | M1 only | |
| $\log_2 727 = …$ | M1 | |
| $… = 9.505…$ and hence 10 | A1 | Answer given correctly to 1 dp |
| $\frac{727}{2^n}$ considered with $n=10$ is M1, showing explicitly that $n=10$ is first value giving less than 1; $\frac{727}{1024}$ or $0.7099…$ must be seen | M1, A1 | Not sufficient to just say $\frac{727}{2^{10}}$ is less than 1 |
| Halving 727 ten times gives value less than or equal to 1, showing $0.70996…$ correct to 1 d.p. | M1, A1 | Accept $= 1$ as halving/dividing by 2 context |
| Answer of 10 with no working | M0 | |

---
1.

$$\begin{aligned}
& \text { Kerry (K) } \\
& \text { Nikki (N) } \\
& \text { Violet (V) } \\
& \text { Dev (D) } \\
& \text { Henri (H) } \\
& \text { Leslie (L) } \\
& \text { Enlai (E) } \\
& \text { Sylvester (S) } \\
& \text { Joan (J) }
\end{aligned}$$

A binary search is to be performed on the names in the list above to locate the name Leslie.
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\item Explain why a binary search cannot be performed with the list in its present form.
\item Using an appropriate algorithm, alter the list so that a binary search can be performed. You should state the name of the algorithm you use and show the list after each complete iteration.
\item Use the binary search algorithm to locate the name Leslie in the altered list you obtained in (b). You must make your method clear.

The binary search algorithm is to be used to search for a name in an alphabetical list of 727 names.
\item Find the maximum number of iterations needed. You should justify your answer.
\end{enumerate}

\hfill \mbox{\textit{Edexcel D1 2018 Q1 [10]}}