OCR Further Additional Pure 2019 June — Question 7 12 marks

Exam BoardOCR
ModuleFurther Additional Pure (Further Additional Pure)
Year2019
SessionJune
Marks12
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicNumber Theory
TypeDiophantine equations
DifficultyChallenging +1.8 This Further Maths question requires surface of revolution integration (a standard but technical formula), followed by two approximation methods involving geometric reasoning and mean value theorem application. While the integration itself is moderately challenging with the given function, the multi-part structure, need for exact rational answers, and conceptual understanding of different approximation methods elevate it above typical A-level questions but it remains a structured problem with clear techniques rather than requiring deep insight.
Spec4.08e Mean value of function: using integral8.06b Arc length and surface area: of revolution, cartesian or parametric

7 The points \(P \left( \frac { 1 } { 2 } , \frac { 13 } { 24 } \right)\) and \(Q \left( \frac { 3 } { 2 } , \frac { 31 } { 24 } \right)\) lie on the curve \(y = \frac { 1 } { 3 } x ^ { 3 } + \frac { 1 } { 4 x }\).
The area of the surface generated when arc \(P Q\) is rotated completely about the \(x\)-axis is denoted by \(A\).
  1. Find the exact value of \(A\). Give your answer as a rational multiple of \(\pi\). Student X finds an approximation to \(A\) by modelling the arc \(P Q\) as the straight line segment \(P Q\), then rotating this line segment completely about the \(x\)-axis to form a surface.
  2. Find the approximation to \(A\) obtained by student X . Give your answer as a rational multiple of \(\pi\). Student Y finds a second approximation to \(A\) by modelling the original curve as the line \(y = M\), where \(M\) is the mean value of the function \(\mathrm { f } ( x ) = \frac { 1 } { 3 } x ^ { 3 } + \frac { 1 } { 4 x }\), then rotating this line completely about the \(x\)-axis to form a surface.
  3. Find the approximation to \(A\) obtained by student Y . Give your answer correct to four decimal places.

Question 7:
AnswerMarks Guidance
7(a) 2 2
dy 1 dy  1   1 
= x2 − ⇒ 1 +   = 1 + x4 − 1 +  or x2 + 
dx 4x2 dx  2 16x4   4x2 
x3 1  1  x5 x 1 
A = 2π∫   +  x2 + dx or 2π∫   + +  dx
 3 4x 4x2   3 3 16x3 
3
 x6 x2 1  2 1145 −95
= 2π + −  = 2π −  = 155 π
 18 6 32x2  576 576  72
 1
AnswerMarks
21.1
1.1a
1.1
AnswerMarks
1.1M1
A1
A1
A1
AnswerMarks
[4]Not necessarily as a perfect square
Correct integrand soi at any stage (any correct form, including
involving a square-root)
BC or from correct integration
AnswerMarks
(b)Line is y = 3 x+ 1 and cuts the x-axis at (− 2, 0)
4 6 9
DR Distance (− 2, 0) to ( 3, 31 ) is ( 31 )2 + ( 31 )2 = 155
9 2 24 18 24 72
Distance (− 2, 0) to ( 1, 13 ) is ( 13 )2 + ( 13 )2 = 65
9 2 24 18 24 72
Curved SA required is π RL−π rl = π ( 31.155 – 13 . 65 ) = 55 π
AnswerMarks
24 72 24 72 243.3
3.4
1.1
AnswerMarks
1.1B1
M1
A1
AnswerMarks
A1Cutting-point on x-axis BC
Attempt at either of the two slant heights (or use of calculus)
Both correct
Cao (possibly BC)
Alt.
Line is y = 3 x+ 1
AnswerMarks
4 6B1
SA = 2π∫ ( 3x+ 1 )( 1+(3)2 ) dx
AnswerMarks Guidance
4 6 4M1 Attempt at surface area integral with y and “ds”
A1Correct integrand in any form (ignore limits for now)
= 55 π
AnswerMarks Guidance
24A1 Cao (possibly BC)
[4]
AnswerMarks
(c)1 1.5x3 1 
Mean value of y is M = ∫   +  dx
3 − 1  3 4x
2 2 0.5
 x4 1 1.5
=  + lnx = 5 + 1ln3 or 0.691 …
12 4  12 4
 0.5
Curved SA cylinder = 2πrh (with r = y , h = 1)
m
( )
= 2π 5 + 1ln3 = 4.3437 to 4 d.p.
AnswerMarks
12 43.3
1.1
AnswerMarks
3.4 1.1M1
A1
M1
A1
AnswerMarks
[4]Attempt to find the mean value of y over this interval
BC
Or by integration
Allow exact answer and condone awrt 4.344 (i.e. to 4 s.f.)
AnswerMarks
(a)DR 2(p−2)p − 2 ≡ 2(–2)p – 2 (mod p) = – (–2)p – 1
≡ – 1 (mod p) by FLT
AnswerMarks
since hcf((–) 2, p) = 12.1 1.2
2.4
AnswerMarks
2.2aM1 A1
A1
E1
AnswerMarks
Alt. I DRE1
Since p and (p – 2) are consecutive odds, hcf(p – 2, p) = 1
AnswerMarks Guidance
and so (p−2)p − 1 ≡ 1 (mod p) by FLTB1
⇒ (p−2)(p−2)p − 2 ≡ 1 (mod p)M1
⇒ (−2)(p−2)p − 2 ≡ 1 (mod p) ⇒ 2(p−2)p − 2 ≡ –1 (mod p)A1 AG correctly reasoned
Alt. II DRM1
A1By the Binomial Theorem
(since each term apart from the last has a factor of p)
Statement only is fine
( ) p−2 ( )
(p−2)p − 2 = pp − 2 + (p – 2) pp − 3 (−2) +   pp − 4 (–2)2 + …
 2 
p−2 ( )
… +   p2 (−2)p − 4 + (p – 2)p(–2)p – 3 + (–2)p – 2 ≡ (–2)p – 2
p−4
(mod p)
AnswerMarks
Then 2(p−2)p − 2≡ –(–2)p – 1 (mod p) and (–2)p – 1 ≡ 1(mod p) byA1
FLT
AnswerMarks Guidance
⇒ result since hcf(– 2, p) = 1E1 Can also argue via (p – 2) but there’s more to justify
[4]
DR mod 3, N ≡ 2×(1)34 −215
≡ 2×1−2=0 since 2odd ≡ 2 (mod 3) and 2even ≡ 1 (mod 3)
( )
2×3434 −215 = 235 × 1734 – 215 = 215 220×1734 −1
( ) ( )( )
220×1734 −1 = 210 ×1717 −1 210 ×1717 +1
Using (a), 2 × 1717 ≡ –1 (mod 19)
so first bracket ≡ –29 – 1 = –513 = – 19 × 27 ≡ 0 (mod 19)
AnswerMarks
and N is a multiple of 193.1a
2.4
3.1a
2.5
3.1a
2.4
AnswerMarks
3.2aM1
A1
B1
M1
M1
M1
AnswerMarks
A1Working mod 3
Fully justified that 3N
Indices work to factor out the 215
Use of the difference-of-two-squares factorisation
Using (a)’s result
Working mod 19 in one or both brackets
Valid conclusion
By the Binomial Theorem
(since each term apart from the last has a factor of p)
Statement only is fine
M1
A1
Alt. (for factor 19)
( )
AnswerMarks Guidance
2×3434 −215 = 235 × 1734 – 215 = 215 220×1734 −1 = 215BB1 Indices work to factor out the 215
mod 19, 218 ≡ 1 by FLTM1 (since 19 is prime and hcf(2, 19) = 1)
B ≡ 22 × 1734 – 1 = (2 × 1717 – 1)( 2 × 1717 + 1)M1 Use of the difference-of-two-squares factorisation
Using (a), second bracket is divisible by 19M1 Using (a)’s result
and N is a multiple of 19A1 Valid conclusion
[7]
Question 7:
7 | (a) | 2 2
dy 1 dy  1   1 
= x2 − ⇒ 1 +   = 1 + x4 − 1 +  or x2 + 
dx 4x2 dx  2 16x4   4x2 
x3 1  1  x5 x 1 
A = 2π∫   +  x2 + dx or 2π∫   + +  dx
 3 4x 4x2   3 3 16x3 
3
 x6 x2 1  2 1145 −95
= 2π + −  = 2π −  = 155 π
 18 6 32x2  576 576  72
 1
2 | 1.1
1.1a
1.1
1.1 | M1
A1
A1
A1
[4] | Not necessarily as a perfect square
Correct integrand soi at any stage (any correct form, including
involving a square-root)
BC or from correct integration
(b) | Line is y = 3 x+ 1 and cuts the x-axis at (− 2, 0)
4 6 9
DR Distance (− 2, 0) to ( 3, 31 ) is ( 31 )2 + ( 31 )2 = 155
9 2 24 18 24 72
Distance (− 2, 0) to ( 1, 13 ) is ( 13 )2 + ( 13 )2 = 65
9 2 24 18 24 72
Curved SA required is π RL−π rl = π ( 31.155 – 13 . 65 ) = 55 π
24 72 24 72 24 | 3.3
3.4
1.1
1.1 | B1
M1
A1
A1 | Cutting-point on x-axis BC
Attempt at either of the two slant heights (or use of calculus)
Both correct
Cao (possibly BC)
Alt.
Line is y = 3 x+ 1
4 6 | B1
SA = 2π∫ ( 3x+ 1 )( 1+(3)2 ) dx
4 6 4 | M1 | Attempt at surface area integral with y and “ds”
A1 | Correct integrand in any form (ignore limits for now)
= 55 π
24 | A1 | Cao (possibly BC)
[4]
(c) | 1 1.5x3 1 
Mean value of y is M = ∫   +  dx
3 − 1  3 4x
2 2 0.5
 x4 1 1.5
=  + lnx = 5 + 1ln3 or 0.691 …
12 4  12 4
 0.5
Curved SA cylinder = 2πrh (with r = y , h = 1)
m
( )
= 2π 5 + 1ln3 = 4.3437 to 4 d.p.
12 4 | 3.3
1.1
3.4 1.1 | M1
A1
M1
A1
[4] | Attempt to find the mean value of y over this interval
BC
Or by integration
Allow exact answer and condone awrt 4.344 (i.e. to 4 s.f.)
(a) | DR 2(p−2)p − 2 ≡ 2(–2)p – 2 (mod p) = – (–2)p – 1
≡ – 1 (mod p) by FLT
since hcf((–) 2, p) = 1 | 2.1 1.2
2.4
2.2a | M1 A1
A1
E1
Alt. I DR | E1
Since p and (p – 2) are consecutive odds, hcf(p – 2, p) = 1
and so (p−2)p − 1 ≡ 1 (mod p) by FLT | B1
⇒ (p−2)(p−2)p − 2 ≡ 1 (mod p) | M1
⇒ (−2)(p−2)p − 2 ≡ 1 (mod p) ⇒ 2(p−2)p − 2 ≡ –1 (mod p) | A1 | AG correctly reasoned
Alt. II DR | M1
A1 | By the Binomial Theorem
(since each term apart from the last has a factor of p)
Statement only is fine
( ) p−2 ( )
(p−2)p − 2 = pp − 2 + (p – 2) pp − 3 (−2) +   pp − 4 (–2)2 + …
 2 
p−2 ( )
… +   p2 (−2)p − 4 + (p – 2)p(–2)p – 3 + (–2)p – 2 ≡ (–2)p – 2
p−4
(mod p)
Then 2(p−2)p − 2≡ –(–2)p – 1 (mod p) and (–2)p – 1 ≡ 1(mod p) by | A1
FLT
⇒ result since hcf(– 2, p) = 1 | E1 | Can also argue via (p – 2) but there’s more to justify
[4]
DR mod 3, N ≡ 2×(1)34 −215
≡ 2×1−2=0 since 2odd ≡ 2 (mod 3) and 2even ≡ 1 (mod 3)
( )
2×3434 −215 = 235 × 1734 – 215 = 215 220×1734 −1
( ) ( )( )
220×1734 −1 = 210 ×1717 −1 210 ×1717 +1
Using (a), 2 × 1717 ≡ –1 (mod 19)
so first bracket ≡ –29 – 1 = –513 = – 19 × 27 ≡ 0 (mod 19)
and N is a multiple of 19 | 3.1a
2.4
3.1a
2.5
3.1a
2.4
3.2a | M1
A1
B1
M1
M1
M1
A1 | Working mod 3
Fully justified that 3 | N
Indices work to factor out the 215
Use of the difference-of-two-squares factorisation
Using (a)’s result
Working mod 19 in one or both brackets
Valid conclusion
By the Binomial Theorem
(since each term apart from the last has a factor of p)
Statement only is fine
M1
A1
Alt. (for factor 19)
( )
2×3434 −215 = 235 × 1734 – 215 = 215 220×1734 −1 = 215B | B1 | Indices work to factor out the 215
mod 19, 218 ≡ 1 by FLT | M1 | (since 19 is prime and hcf(2, 19) = 1)
B ≡ 22 × 1734 – 1 = (2 × 1717 – 1)( 2 × 1717 + 1) | M1 | Use of the difference-of-two-squares factorisation
Using (a), second bracket is divisible by 19 | M1 | Using (a)’s result
and N is a multiple of 19 | A1 | Valid conclusion
[7]
7 The points $P \left( \frac { 1 } { 2 } , \frac { 13 } { 24 } \right)$ and $Q \left( \frac { 3 } { 2 } , \frac { 31 } { 24 } \right)$ lie on the curve $y = \frac { 1 } { 3 } x ^ { 3 } + \frac { 1 } { 4 x }$.\\
The area of the surface generated when arc $P Q$ is rotated completely about the $x$-axis is denoted by $A$.
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\item Find the exact value of $A$. Give your answer as a rational multiple of $\pi$.

Student X finds an approximation to $A$ by modelling the arc $P Q$ as the straight line segment $P Q$, then rotating this line segment completely about the $x$-axis to form a surface.
\item Find the approximation to $A$ obtained by student X . Give your answer as a rational multiple of $\pi$.

Student Y finds a second approximation to $A$ by modelling the original curve as the line $y = M$, where $M$ is the mean value of the function $\mathrm { f } ( x ) = \frac { 1 } { 3 } x ^ { 3 } + \frac { 1 } { 4 x }$, then rotating this line completely about the $x$-axis to form a surface.
\item Find the approximation to $A$ obtained by student Y . Give your answer correct to four decimal places.
\end{enumerate}

\hfill \mbox{\textit{OCR Further Additional Pure 2019 Q7 [12]}}