OCR MEI S1 — Question 2 19 marks

Exam BoardOCR MEI
ModuleS1 (Statistics 1)
Marks19
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicData representation
TypeOutliers from box plot or summary statistics
DifficultyModerate -0.5 This is a multi-part question combining basic box plot interpretation (finding IQR and outliers using the 1.5×IQR rule) with straightforward probability calculations involving combinations and conditional probability. While it requires multiple techniques, each component is standard A-level material with no novel insight required—the probability calculations are routine applications of formulas for sampling without replacement.
Spec2.02f Measures of average and spread2.02h Recognize outliers2.03a Mutually exclusive and independent events2.03c Conditional probability: using diagrams/tables

2 The box and whisker plot below summarises the weights in grams of the 20 chocolates in a box. \includegraphics[max width=\textwidth, alt={}, center]{452a52c9-b1fa-4b98-a85d-a34ba0f84a9d-1_290_1186_1099_452}
  1. Find the interquartile range of the data and hence determine whether there are any outliers at either end of the distribution. Ben buys a box of these chocolates each weekend. The chocolates all look the same on the outside, but 7 of them have orange centres, 6 have cherry centres, 4 have coffee centres and 3 have lemon centres. One weekend, each of Ben's 3 children eats one of the chocolates, chosen at random.
  2. Calculate the probabilities of the following events. A: all 3 chocolates have orange centres \(B\) : all 3 chocolates have the same centres
  3. Find \(\mathrm { P } ( A \mid B )\) and \(\mathrm { P } ( B \mid A )\). The following weekend, Ben buys an identical box of chocolates and again each of his 3 children eats one of the chocolates, chosen at random.
  4. Find the probability that, on both weekends, the 3 chocolates that they eat all have orange centres.
  5. Ben likes all of the chocolates except those with cherry centres. On another weekend he is the first of his family to eat some of the chocolates. Find the probability that he has to select more than 2 chocolates before he finds one that he likes.

Question 2:
Part (i)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMarks Guidance
Inter-quartile range \(= 18.1 - 17.8 = 0.3\)B1
Lower limit \(17.8 - (1.5 \times 0.3)\) \((= 17.35)\); No outliers at lower end.M1, A1 dep on 17.35 — FT their IQR for M marks only. Allow 'No values below 17.35 for first A1'. Allow 'Lower limit \(= 17.35\) so no outliers (at lower end)'. Watch for use of median giving 17.45 which gets M0A0. You must be convinced that comments about no outliers refer to lower tail only.
Upper limit \(18.1 + (1.5 \times 0.3)\) \((= 18.55)\); (Max is 18.6) so at least one outlier at upper end.M1, A1 dep on 18.55 — Allow 'At least one value above 18.55' for second A1. Allow 'any value above 18.55 is an outlier' so at least one outlier. Do not allow 'There MAY be one outlier'. Condone 'one outlier'. Condone 'there are outliers'. Watch for use of median giving 18.35 which gets M0A0.
Total: [5]
Part (ii)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMarks Guidance
\(P(A) = P(\text{All 3 have orange centres}) = \frac{7}{20} \times \frac{6}{19} \times \frac{5}{18} = \frac{7}{228}\)M1 For \(\frac{7}{20}\times\)
M1For product of correct three fractions without extra terms
\(= 0.0307\ (0.030702)\)A1 CAO — Allow full marks for fully simplified fractional answers
Alternative scheme \(^7C_3/^{20}C_3 = 35/1140 = 7/228 = 0.0307\): M1 for either term in correct position in a fraction, M1 for correct fraction, A1 CAO
AnswerMarks Guidance
\(P(B) = P(\text{All 3 have same centres})\) \(= \left(\frac{7}{20}\times\frac{6}{19}\times\frac{5}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\times\frac{4}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{4}{20}\times\frac{3}{19}\times\frac{2}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{3}{20}\times\frac{2}{19}\times\frac{1}{18}\right)\)M1 For at least two correct triple products or fractions or decimals
\(= 0.0307 + 0.0175 + 0.0035 + 0.0009\)M1 For sum of all four correct
\(= 0.0526 = \frac{1}{19}\ (0.052632)\) \(\left(=\frac{7}{228}+\frac{1}{57}+\frac{1}{285}+\frac{1}{1140}\right)\)A1 CAO — Allow 0.053 or anything which rounds to 0.053 with working
Total: [6]
Part (iii)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMarks Guidance
\(P(A\mid B) = \dfrac{0.0307..}{0.0526..}\)M1 For their \(A\) divided by their \(B\) — Allow 0.584 from \(\frac{0.0307}{0.0526}\)
\(= 0.583\ (= 0.58333)\)A1 FT their answers to (ii) provided answer \(< 1\) — Allow \(\frac{7}{12}\)
\(P(B\mid A) = 1\)B1 CAO
Total: [3]
Part (iv)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMarks Guidance
\(P(\text{All have orange centres}) = 0.0307^2 = 0.00094\) or \(\frac{49}{51984}\) \((= 0.00094260)\)M1 For their \(0.0307^2\) — Allow \(9.4 \times 10^{-4}\), condone 0.0009 or \(9 \times 10^{-4}\)
A1FT
Total: [2]
Part (v)
AnswerMarks Guidance
AnswerMarks Guidance
\(P(\text{Has to select} > 2) = 1 - P(\text{Has to select} \leq 2)\) \(= 1 - \left(\frac{14}{20}+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{14}{19}\right)\right) = 1-(0.7+0.221) = 1-0.921\)M1 For \(\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{14}{19}\right)\) — For any of the methods below allow SC2 for \(1-0.079 = 0.921\) or \(1 - 3/38 = 35/38\) o.e. as final answer. This is \(1 - P(C' + CC')\)
M1For \(1 -\) sum of both
\(= 0.079\ (=0.078947)\)A1 CAO
Total: [3]
OR: \(P(\text{Has to select} > 2) = P(\text{First 2 both cherry}) = \left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\right)\)
AnswerMarks Guidance
M2For whole product — Without extra terms added. M1 if multiplied by \(k/18\) only where \(0
\(= 0.079 = \frac{3}{38}\)A1 CAO
OR: \(1-(P(\text{0 cherries})+P(\text{1 cherry}))\)
\(= 1-\left(\frac{14}{20}\times\frac{13}{19}+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{14}{19}\right)+\left(\frac{14}{20}\times\frac{6}{19}\right)\right)\)
\(= 1-(0.4789+0.2211+0.2211) = 1-0.9209\)
AnswerMarks Guidance
M1For any term — This is \(1-P(C'C'+CC'+C'C)\)
M1For \(1 -\) sum of all three
\(= 0.079\)A1 CAO
OR (full enumeration method):
\(\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\times\frac{14}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\times\frac{4}{18}\times\frac{14}{17}\right)+\ldots\)
AnswerMarks Guidance
M1For any term — This is \(P(CCC'+CCCC'+CCCCC'+CCCCCC')\)
\(= \frac{7}{114}+\frac{14}{969}+\frac{7}{2584}+\frac{7}{19380}+\frac{1}{38760}\)M1 For sum of all five terms (all correct)
\(= 0.079\)A1 CAO
# Question 2:

## Part (i)

| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|--------|-------|----------|
| Inter-quartile range $= 18.1 - 17.8 = 0.3$ | B1 | |
| Lower limit $17.8 - (1.5 \times 0.3)$ $(= 17.35)$; No outliers at lower end. | M1, A1 | dep on 17.35 — FT their IQR for M marks only. Allow 'No values below 17.35 for first A1'. Allow 'Lower limit $= 17.35$ so no outliers (at lower end)'. Watch for use of median giving 17.45 which gets M0A0. You must be convinced that comments about no outliers refer to lower tail only. |
| Upper limit $18.1 + (1.5 \times 0.3)$ $(= 18.55)$; (Max is 18.6) so at least one outlier at upper end. | M1, A1 | dep on 18.55 — Allow 'At least one value above 18.55' for second A1. Allow 'any value above 18.55 is an outlier' so at least one outlier. Do not allow 'There MAY be one outlier'. Condone 'one outlier'. Condone 'there are outliers'. Watch for use of median giving 18.35 which gets M0A0. |

**Total: [5]**

## Part (ii)

| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $P(A) = P(\text{All 3 have orange centres}) = \frac{7}{20} \times \frac{6}{19} \times \frac{5}{18} = \frac{7}{228}$ | M1 | For $\frac{7}{20}\times$ |
| | M1 | For product of correct three fractions without extra terms |
| $= 0.0307\ (0.030702)$ | A1 | CAO — Allow full marks for fully simplified fractional answers |

**Alternative scheme** $^7C_3/^{20}C_3 = 35/1140 = 7/228 = 0.0307$: M1 for either term in correct position in a fraction, M1 for correct fraction, A1 CAO

| $P(B) = P(\text{All 3 have same centres})$ $= \left(\frac{7}{20}\times\frac{6}{19}\times\frac{5}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\times\frac{4}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{4}{20}\times\frac{3}{19}\times\frac{2}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{3}{20}\times\frac{2}{19}\times\frac{1}{18}\right)$ | M1 | For at least two correct triple products or fractions or decimals |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $= 0.0307 + 0.0175 + 0.0035 + 0.0009$ | M1 | For sum of all four correct |
| $= 0.0526 = \frac{1}{19}\ (0.052632)$ $\left(=\frac{7}{228}+\frac{1}{57}+\frac{1}{285}+\frac{1}{1140}\right)$ | A1 | CAO — Allow 0.053 or anything which rounds to 0.053 with working |

**Total: [6]**

## Part (iii)

| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $P(A\mid B) = \dfrac{0.0307..}{0.0526..}$ | M1 | For their $A$ divided by their $B$ — Allow 0.584 from $\frac{0.0307}{0.0526}$ |
| $= 0.583\ (= 0.58333)$ | A1 | FT their answers to (ii) provided answer $< 1$ — Allow $\frac{7}{12}$ |
| $P(B\mid A) = 1$ | B1 | CAO |

**Total: [3]**

## Part (iv)

| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $P(\text{All have orange centres}) = 0.0307^2 = 0.00094$ or $\frac{49}{51984}$ $(= 0.00094260)$ | M1 | For their $0.0307^2$ — Allow $9.4 \times 10^{-4}$, condone 0.0009 or $9 \times 10^{-4}$ |
| | A1 | FT |

**Total: [2]**

## Part (v)

| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $P(\text{Has to select} > 2) = 1 - P(\text{Has to select} \leq 2)$ $= 1 - \left(\frac{14}{20}+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{14}{19}\right)\right) = 1-(0.7+0.221) = 1-0.921$ | M1 | For $\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{14}{19}\right)$ — For any of the methods below allow SC2 for $1-0.079 = 0.921$ or $1 - 3/38 = 35/38$ o.e. as final answer. This is $1 - P(C' + CC')$ |
| | M1 | For $1 -$ sum of both |
| $= 0.079\ (=0.078947)$ | A1 | CAO |

**Total: [3]**

**OR:** $P(\text{Has to select} > 2) = P(\text{First 2 both cherry}) = \left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\right)$

| | M2 | For whole product — Without extra terms added. M1 if multiplied by $k/18$ only where $0<k<18$. This is $P(CC)$. |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $= 0.079 = \frac{3}{38}$ | A1 | CAO |

**OR:** $1-(P(\text{0 cherries})+P(\text{1 cherry}))$
$= 1-\left(\frac{14}{20}\times\frac{13}{19}+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{14}{19}\right)+\left(\frac{14}{20}\times\frac{6}{19}\right)\right)$
$= 1-(0.4789+0.2211+0.2211) = 1-0.9209$

| | M1 | For any term — This is $1-P(C'C'+CC'+C'C)$ |
|--------|-------|----------|
| | M1 | For $1 -$ sum of all three |
| $= 0.079$ | A1 | CAO |

**OR** (full enumeration method):
$\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\times\frac{14}{18}\right)+\left(\frac{6}{20}\times\frac{5}{19}\times\frac{4}{18}\times\frac{14}{17}\right)+\ldots$

| | M1 | For any term — This is $P(CCC'+CCCC'+CCCCC'+CCCCCC')$ |
|--------|-------|----------|
| $= \frac{7}{114}+\frac{14}{969}+\frac{7}{2584}+\frac{7}{19380}+\frac{1}{38760}$ | M1 | For sum of all five terms (all correct) |
| $= 0.079$ | A1 | CAO |
2 The box and whisker plot below summarises the weights in grams of the 20 chocolates in a box.\\
\includegraphics[max width=\textwidth, alt={}, center]{452a52c9-b1fa-4b98-a85d-a34ba0f84a9d-1_290_1186_1099_452}\\
(i) Find the interquartile range of the data and hence determine whether there are any outliers at either end of the distribution.

Ben buys a box of these chocolates each weekend. The chocolates all look the same on the outside, but 7 of them have orange centres, 6 have cherry centres, 4 have coffee centres and 3 have lemon centres.

One weekend, each of Ben's 3 children eats one of the chocolates, chosen at random.\\
(ii) Calculate the probabilities of the following events.

A: all 3 chocolates have orange centres\\
$B$ : all 3 chocolates have the same centres\\
(iii) Find $\mathrm { P } ( A \mid B )$ and $\mathrm { P } ( B \mid A )$.

The following weekend, Ben buys an identical box of chocolates and again each of his 3 children eats one of the chocolates, chosen at random.\\
(iv) Find the probability that, on both weekends, the 3 chocolates that they eat all have orange centres.\\
(v) Ben likes all of the chocolates except those with cherry centres. On another weekend he is the first of his family to eat some of the chocolates. Find the probability that he has to select more than 2 chocolates before he finds one that he likes.

\hfill \mbox{\textit{OCR MEI S1  Q2 [19]}}