CAIE M1 2024 November — Question 7 10 marks

Exam BoardCAIE
ModuleM1 (Mechanics 1)
Year2024
SessionNovember
Marks10
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicPulley systems
TypeHeavier particle hits ground, lighter continues upward - vertical strings
DifficultyStandard +0.3 This is a standard two-particle pulley system problem requiring application of Newton's second law, constant acceleration equations, and understanding of motion phases. Part (a) involves routine setup of equations for connected particles and solving simultaneous equations. Part (b) requires tracking motion through multiple phases (ascent, descent) using kinematic equations. While multi-step, all techniques are standard M1 content with no novel insight required, making it slightly easier than average.
Spec3.02h Motion under gravity: vector form3.03k Connected particles: pulleys and equilibrium

\includegraphics{figure_7} Two particles, \(A\) and \(B\), of masses 3 kg and 5 kg respectively, are connected by a light inextensible string that passes over a fixed smooth pulley. The particles are held with the string taut and its straight parts vertical. Particle \(A\) is 1 m above a horizontal plane, and particle \(B\) is 2 m above the plane (see diagram). The particles are released from rest. In the subsequent motion, \(A\) does not reach the pulley, and after \(B\) reaches the plane it remains in contact with the plane.
  1. Find the tension in the string and the time taken for \(B\) to reach the plane. [6]
  2. Find the time for which \(A\) is at least 3.25 m above the plane. [4]

Question 7:

AnswerMarks
7(a)T −3g =3a
5g−T =5a
AnswerMarks Guidance
5g−3g =(3+5)a*B1 For one correct equation.
*B1For any two correct consistent equations. If tensions T and T
A B
both stated must at some point state or imply that they are equal to
score the second B1.
AnswerMarks Guidance
Attempt to solve for TDM1 May find a first a=2.5  Must get to 'T='. Dep on both B
marks.
75
T =37.5N or N
AnswerMarks Guidance
2A1 Allow without working.
Correct use of suvat with their a and solve for tDM1 E.g. 2=0.52.5t2 Must get to 't='. Dep on both B marks or
the B1 for the equation 5g−3g =(3+5)a if this used to find a,
but not on first M1 mark.
0+their 10
Could find v= 10 then use 2= t .
2
40 2 10
t=1 .26 or or
AnswerMarks Guidance
5 5A1 t=1.2649 If candidates do not try to find T but do attempt to
find the time, they can score B1B1M0A0M1A1. Do not allow if
also give negative answer and do not discard. Note:
t = 1.6only, scores A0 .
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks
7(a)Alternative for final 2 marks, even if nothing scored earlier
Use of energy to find velocity at plane and then suvat to find tM1 1 1
PE loss = KE gain: 5g2−3g2 = 5v2 + 3v2,
2 2
Or PE loss – WD by tension = KE gain: 5g2−their 37.52 =
1
5v2 ,
2
Or WD by tension – PE gain = KE gain:
1
their 37.52−3g2= 3v2 ,
2
0+v
v= 10 or v=3.16 then 2= t,
2
Dependent on both B marks only if candidate uses tension, but
otherwise not dependent on either B mark.
40 2 10
t= 1.6 =1.26 or or
 
AnswerMarks Guidance
5 5A1 t=1.2649
6
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks

AnswerMarks
7(b)Correct use of suvat before B hits the plane or when A has risen 2
m, to attempt to find velocity of A when string becomes slack
AnswerMarks Guidance
Using their a and/or their t.*M1 v2 =0+22.52. Must use s=2 and u=0,
OR v=0+2.5 1.6 Must use u=0 ,
1
OR 2= (0+v) 1.6 Must use s=2 and u=0.
2
Must be complete method to find v or v2 v= 10 .
 
Could have found v= 10 in part (a) and give M1 if used in part
(b).
Correct use of suvat for motion of A (between height of 3m and
AnswerMarks Guidance
3.25 m), to form an equation in t, using a=−g*DM1 3.25−3= ( their 10 ) t+0.5(−10)t2.
Solving a 3 term quadratic for t to get at least one (unsimplified)
AnswerMarks Guidance
value using their 2.5 (or using any other correct method)DM1 10− 5 10+ 5
If correct should get t=0.093,0.540 or , ,
10 10
0.09262… or 0.53978…
Could use formula and realise that the time for at least 3.25 m,
b2 −4ac 10−450.25
=2 =2 which gets DM1.
2a 25
5 1
Time = 0.447 s or s or
AnswerMarks Guidance
5 5A1 Time =0.53978−0.09262 = 0.44721…
 10 10− 5
2 −  = 0.44721…
 
 1 0 10 
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks
7(b)Alternative for last 3 marks of Q7(b) finding max height
For attempt to find max height using correct suvat with a=−g*DM1 02 = ( their 10 )2 +2(−10)s Where s is distance above 3
metres.
(which leads to a maximum height of 3.5 m).
AnswerMarks Guidance
For attempt to find time from .25 m below top to topDM1 5
t= 0.224 or [0.22360….] probably from
10
3.5−3.25=0t+0.510t2. Dep on both previous M1s.
 
5
Time = 0.447 s or s
AnswerMarks Guidance
5A1 For doubling.
Alternative for last 3 marks of Q7(b) by finding velocity at height of 3.25 m
Correct use of suvat for motion of A (between height of 3m and
AnswerMarks Guidance
3.25 m), to form an equation to find speed at height of 3.25 m*DM1 w2 =their 10 2 +2(−g)0.25. w2 =5 or w= 5.
   
AnswerMarks Guidance
For correct use of suvat to find time to max heightDM1  5
0= 5+(−g)t t =  .
 10 
5
Time = 0.447 s or s
AnswerMarks Guidance
5A1 For doubling.
QuestionAnswer Marks
7(b)Alternative using energy
Correct use of energy before B hits the plane or when A has risen 2
m, to attempt to find velocity of A when string becomes slack
AnswerMarks Guidance
using their T if necessary.*M1 1 1
PE loss = KE gain: 5g2−3g2 = 5v2 + 3v2,
2 2
Or PE loss – WD by tension = KE gain: 5g2−their 37.52 =
1
5v2 ,
2
Or WD by tension – PE gain = KE gain:
1
their 37.52−3g2= 3v2 .
2
Must be complete method to find v or v2 v= 10 or 3.162.
 
Do not allow sign errors.
AnswerMarks Guidance
Correct use of energy to find velocity of A at height of 3.25 m*DM1 1 2 1
PE gain = KE loss: 3g0.25= 3 10 − 3w2 .
2 2
Must be complete method to find w or w2 w= 5 or 2.236
Do not allow sign errors.
AnswerMarks Guidance
For attempt to find time from .25 m below top to topDM1 5
t= 0.224 or [0.22360….] probably from 0= 5−10t .
10
Dep on both previous M1s.
Do not allow sign errors.
5
Time = 0.447 s or s
AnswerMarks Guidance
5A1 For doubling.
4
Question 7:
--- 7(a) ---
7(a) | T −3g =3a
5g−T =5a
5g−3g =(3+5)a | *B1 | For one correct equation.
*B1 | For any two correct consistent equations. If tensions T and T
A B
both stated must at some point state or imply that they are equal to
score the second B1.
Attempt to solve for T | DM1 | May find a first a=2.5  Must get to 'T='. Dep on both B
marks.
75
T =37.5N or N
2 | A1 | Allow without working.
Correct use of suvat with their a and solve for t | DM1 | E.g. 2=0.52.5t2 Must get to 't='. Dep on both B marks or
the B1 for the equation 5g−3g =(3+5)a if this used to find a,
but not on first M1 mark.
0+their 10
Could find v= 10 then use 2= t .
2
40 2 10
t=1 .26 or or
5 5 | A1 | t=1.2649 If candidates do not try to find T but do attempt to
find the time, they can score B1B1M0A0M1A1. Do not allow if
also give negative answer and do not discard. Note:
t = 1.6only, scores A0 .
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
7(a) | Alternative for final 2 marks, even if nothing scored earlier
Use of energy to find velocity at plane and then suvat to find t | M1 | 1 1
PE loss = KE gain: 5g2−3g2 = 5v2 + 3v2,
2 2
Or PE loss – WD by tension = KE gain: 5g2−their 37.52 =
1
5v2 ,
2
Or WD by tension – PE gain = KE gain:
1
their 37.52−3g2= 3v2 ,
2
0+v
v= 10 or v=3.16 then 2= t,
2
Dependent on both B marks only if candidate uses tension, but
otherwise not dependent on either B mark.
40 2 10
t= 1.6 =1.26 or or
 
5 5 | A1 | t=1.2649
6
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
--- 7(b) ---
7(b) | Correct use of suvat before B hits the plane or when A has risen 2
m, to attempt to find velocity of A when string becomes slack
Using their a and/or their t. | *M1 | v2 =0+22.52. Must use s=2 and u=0,
OR v=0+2.5 1.6 Must use u=0 ,
1
OR 2= (0+v) 1.6 Must use s=2 and u=0.
2
Must be complete method to find v or v2 v= 10 .
 
Could have found v= 10 in part (a) and give M1 if used in part
(b).
Correct use of suvat for motion of A (between height of 3m and
3.25 m), to form an equation in t, using a=−g | *DM1 | 3.25−3= ( their 10 ) t+0.5(−10)t2.
Solving a 3 term quadratic for t to get at least one (unsimplified)
value using their 2.5 (or using any other correct method) | DM1 | 10− 5 10+ 5
If correct should get t=0.093,0.540 or , ,
10 10
0.09262… or 0.53978…
Could use formula and realise that the time for at least 3.25 m,
b2 −4ac 10−450.25
=2 =2 which gets DM1.
2a 25
5 1
Time = 0.447 s or s or
5 5 | A1 | Time =0.53978−0.09262 = 0.44721…
 10 10− 5
2 −  = 0.44721…
 
 1 0 10 
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
7(b) | Alternative for last 3 marks of Q7(b) finding max height
For attempt to find max height using correct suvat with a=−g | *DM1 | 02 = ( their 10 )2 +2(−10)s Where s is distance above 3
metres.
(which leads to a maximum height of 3.5 m).
For attempt to find time from .25 m below top to top | DM1 | 5
t= 0.224 or [0.22360….] probably from
10
3.5−3.25=0t+0.510t2. Dep on both previous M1s.
 
5
Time = 0.447 s or s
5 | A1 | For doubling.
Alternative for last 3 marks of Q7(b) by finding velocity at height of 3.25 m
Correct use of suvat for motion of A (between height of 3m and
3.25 m), to form an equation to find speed at height of 3.25 m | *DM1 | w2 =their 10 2 +2(−g)0.25. w2 =5 or w= 5.
   
For correct use of suvat to find time to max height | DM1 |  5
0= 5+(−g)t t =  .
 10 
5
Time = 0.447 s or s
5 | A1 | For doubling.
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
7(b) | Alternative using energy
Correct use of energy before B hits the plane or when A has risen 2
m, to attempt to find velocity of A when string becomes slack
using their T if necessary. | *M1 | 1 1
PE loss = KE gain: 5g2−3g2 = 5v2 + 3v2,
2 2
Or PE loss – WD by tension = KE gain: 5g2−their 37.52 =
1
5v2 ,
2
Or WD by tension – PE gain = KE gain:
1
their 37.52−3g2= 3v2 .
2
Must be complete method to find v or v2 v= 10 or 3.162.
 
Do not allow sign errors.
Correct use of energy to find velocity of A at height of 3.25 m | *DM1 | 1 2 1
PE gain = KE loss: 3g0.25= 3 10 − 3w2 .
2 2
Must be complete method to find w or w2 w= 5 or 2.236
Do not allow sign errors.
For attempt to find time from .25 m below top to top | DM1 | 5
t= 0.224 or [0.22360….] probably from 0= 5−10t .
10
Dep on both previous M1s.
Do not allow sign errors.
5
Time = 0.447 s or s
5 | A1 | For doubling.
4
\includegraphics{figure_7}

Two particles, $A$ and $B$, of masses 3 kg and 5 kg respectively, are connected by a light inextensible string that passes over a fixed smooth pulley. The particles are held with the string taut and its straight parts vertical. Particle $A$ is 1 m above a horizontal plane, and particle $B$ is 2 m above the plane (see diagram).

The particles are released from rest. In the subsequent motion, $A$ does not reach the pulley, and after $B$ reaches the plane it remains in contact with the plane.

\begin{enumerate}[label=(\alph*)]
\item Find the tension in the string and the time taken for $B$ to reach the plane. [6]

\item Find the time for which $A$ is at least 3.25 m above the plane. [4]
\end{enumerate}

\hfill \mbox{\textit{CAIE M1 2024 Q7 [10]}}