CAIE FP2 2018 November — Question 10 12 marks

Exam BoardCAIE
ModuleFP2 (Further Pure Mathematics 2)
Year2018
SessionNovember
Marks12
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicHypothesis test of a Poisson distribution
TypeComment on test validity or assumptions
DifficultyStandard +0.8 This is a standard chi-squared goodness-of-fit test for a Poisson distribution with routine calculations (mean, variance, expected frequencies) and hypothesis testing. While it requires multiple steps and understanding of when to combine cells, it follows a well-established procedure taught in Further Statistics. The conceptual demand is moderate—recognizing mean ≈ variance suggests Poisson, calculating expected frequencies using the Poisson formula, and applying the chi-squared test with appropriate degrees of freedom. This is more challenging than basic A-level statistics due to the Further Maths context and multi-part nature, but remains a textbook-style question without requiring novel insight.
Spec5.02i Poisson distribution: random events model5.02k Calculate Poisson probabilities5.06c Fit other distributions: discrete and continuous

The number of accidents, \(x\), that occur each day on a motorway are recorded over a period of 40 days. The results are shown in the following table.
Number of accidents0123456\(\geqslant 7\)
Observed frequency358105720
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)] \item Show that the mean number of accidents each day is 2.95 and calculate the variance for this sample. Explain why these values suggest that a Poisson distribution might fit the data. [3] \item A Poisson distribution with mean 2.95, as found from the data, is used to calculate the expected frequencies, correct to 2 decimal places. The results are shown in the following table.
Number of accidents0123456\(\geqslant 7\)
Observed frequency358105720
Expected frequency2.096.189.118.966.613.901.921.23
Show how the expected frequency of 6.61 for \(x = 4\) is obtained. [2] \item Test at the 5% significance level the goodness of fit of this Poisson distribution to the data. [7] \end{enumerate]

Question 10:

AnswerMarks Guidance
10(i)x = Σ x f(x) = 118/40 = 2.95 AG B1
σ2 = (454 – 1182/40) / 40 = 2.65
n
or σ 2 = (454 – 1182/40) / 39 = 2.72
AnswerMarks Guidance
n–1B1 Find variance of sample data (accept either σ2 or σ 2 )
n n–1
AnswerMarks Guidance
2.95 ≈ 2.65 or 2.72B1 Valid comment on correct values
3
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks

AnswerMarks
10(ii)E = 40 λ4 e–λ /4! with λ = 2.95 [= 40 × 0.1652]
4
(allow (λ/4) × E = 0.7375 × 8.96)
AnswerMarks Guidance
3M1A1 State expression for reqd. expected value E
4
2

AnswerMarks Guidance
10(iii)H : [Poisson] distribution fits data (AEF)
0B1 State (at least) null hypothesis in full
O: 8 8 10 5 9
i
E: 8.27 9.11 8.96 6.61 7.05
AnswerMarks Guidance
iM1 Combine values consistent with all exp. values ⩾ 5
X2 = 0.0088 + 0.1352 + 0.1207 + 0.3921 + 0.5394M1 Find value of X2 from Σ (E – O)2 / E [or Σ O2/E – n ]
i i i i i
AnswerMarks
= 1.20 (to 3 s.f.)A1
No. n of cells: 8 7 6 5
χ 2: 12.59 11.07 9.488 7.815
AnswerMarks Guidance
n–2, 0.95B1 State or use consistent tabular value χ 2 (to 3 s.f.)
n–2, 0.95
[FT on number, n, of cells used to find X2]
Accept H if X2 < tabular value (AEF)
AnswerMarks Guidance
0M1 State or imply valid method for conclusion
1.20 [± 0.1] < 7.81[5] so [Poisson] distn. fits [data]
AnswerMarks Guidance
or distn. is a suitable model (AEF)A1 Conclusion (requires both values correct)
7
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks
11A(i)EITHER: 40 e / 0.8 = 2g, e = 0.4 [or OP = 1.2] [m]
0 0 0M1A1 Find extension e [or OP ] at equilibrium position P
0 0 0
2 d2x/dt2 = – 40 (e + x) / 0.8 + 2g
0
or = + 40 (e – x) / 0.8 – 2g
AnswerMarks Guidance
0M1A1 Use Newton’s law at general point (e.g. x below or above P )
0
(ignore LHS sign here only)
OR: 2 d2y/dt2 = – 40 (y – 0.8) / 0.8 + 2g
AnswerMarks Guidance
= – 50 y + 60(M1A1 Use Newton’s law at general point in terms of y = OP
(ignore LHS sign here only)
AnswerMarks Guidance
Take x = y – 1.2 to giveM1A1) Change variable to give standard form of SHM eqn
d2x/dt2 = – 25xA1 Hence SHM (A0 if wrong sign or LHS unclear)
(B1 only for stating SHM eqn. without proof)
AnswerMarks Guidance
T = 2π / √(25) = 2π/5 AGA1 Verify period T using T = 2π/ω with ω = √(25)
OP = 1.2 [m]
AnswerMarks Guidance
0B1 State OP explicitly (may imply first M1 A1)
0
7
AnswerMarks Guidance
11A(ii)0.42 = 25 (a2 – 0.062) M1A1
a = √(0.0064 + 0.0036) = 0.1 [m]A1
3
AnswerMarks
11A(iii)40 e / 0.8 = (2 + M) g, [e = 0.4 + 0.2 M]
1 1
or 40(e – e ) / 0.8 = Mg [e – e = 0.2 M]
AnswerMarks Guidance
1 0 1 0M1A1 Find extension e [or OP ] at first equilibrium position P
1 1 1
or equate additional extension to M by Hooke’s Law
e – e = a , M = a/0.2 = 0.5
AnswerMarks Guidance
1 0M1A1 Find M by relating e , e and a
0 1
4
AnswerMarks Guidance
QuestionAnswer Marks
11B(i)H : µ = µ , H : µ > µ (or in terms of µ , µ )
0 x y 1 x y A BB1 State hypotheses (B0 forx …)
s 2 = (14.1775 – 10.562/8) / 7 = 0.03404 and
x
s 2 = (15.894 – 12.392/10) / 9 = 0.06031 (to 3 s.f.)
AnswerMarks Guidance
yM1A1 Estimate both population variances
(allow biased here: 0.02979 and 0.05428)
s2 = (7 s 2 + 9 s 2) / 16
x y
or (14.1775 – 10.562/8 + 15.894 – 12.392/10) / 16
AnswerMarks Guidance
= 0.78 109 / 16 or 0.04882 or 0.220952 (to 3 s.f.)M1A1 Find pooled estimate of common variance
(M1 A1 for s 2 and s 2 may be implied here)
x y
t = 1.337 (to 3 s.f.)
AnswerMarks Guidance
16. 0.9*B1 State or use correct tabular t value
t = (1.32 – 1.239) / s√(1/10 + 1/8) = 0.773M1A1 Calculate value of t (or –t)
(or can comparey –x = 0.081 with 0.140)
t < tabular value
AnswerMarks Guidance
so claim not justified or A’s not heavier than B’s (AEF)B1 Correct conclusion (FT on t, dep *B1)
SC: z = (1.32 – 1.239) / √(s 2/8 + s 2/10)
x y
AnswerMarks Guidance
= 0.081 / √(0.078) = 0.799(B1 SC: Implicitly taking s 2, s 2 as unequal popln. variances
x y
(may also earn first B1 M1 A1)
AnswerMarks Guidance
z < 1.282 so claim is not justified (AEF)B1) Comparison with z and conclusion (FT on z; max 5/9)
0.9
9
AnswerMarks Guidance
11B(ii)x = 1.28 and s2 = 0.294 / 7 [= 0.042 (or 0.2052)] M1
t = (1.28 – p) / √(0.042/8) (AEF)M1A1 Find value of t
t > 1.415 (< is A0), p < 1.28 – 0.1025, p = 1.18
AnswerMarks Guidance
maxM1A1 Find p by comparison with tabular value, here t
max 7. 0.9
5
Question 10:
--- 10(i) ---
10(i) | x = Σ x f(x) = 118/40 = 2.95 AG | B1 | Verify mean of sample data (B0 for x = 118/40 = 2.95)
σ2 = (454 – 1182/40) / 40 = 2.65
n
or σ 2 = (454 – 1182/40) / 39 = 2.72
n–1 | B1 | Find variance of sample data (accept either σ2 or σ 2 )
n n–1
2.95 ≈ 2.65 or 2.72 | B1 | Valid comment on correct values
3
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
--- 10(ii) ---
10(ii) | E = 40 λ4 e–λ /4! with λ = 2.95 [= 40 × 0.1652]
4
(allow (λ/4) × E = 0.7375 × 8.96)
3 | M1A1 | State expression for reqd. expected value E
4
2
--- 10(iii) ---
10(iii) | H : [Poisson] distribution fits data (AEF)
0 | B1 | State (at least) null hypothesis in full
O: 8 8 10 5 9
i
E: 8.27 9.11 8.96 6.61 7.05
i | M1 | Combine values consistent with all exp. values ⩾ 5
X2 = 0.0088 + 0.1352 + 0.1207 + 0.3921 + 0.5394 | M1 | Find value of X2 from Σ (E – O)2 / E [or Σ O2/E – n ]
i i i i i
= 1.20 (to 3 s.f.) | A1
No. n of cells: 8 7 6 5
χ 2: 12.59 11.07 9.488 7.815
n–2, 0.95 | B1 | State or use consistent tabular value χ 2 (to 3 s.f.)
n–2, 0.95
[FT on number, n, of cells used to find X2]
Accept H if X2 < tabular value (AEF)
0 | M1 | State or imply valid method for conclusion
1.20 [± 0.1] < 7.81[5] so [Poisson] distn. fits [data]
or distn. is a suitable model (AEF) | A1 | Conclusion (requires both values correct)
7
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
11A(i) | EITHER: 40 e / 0.8 = 2g, e = 0.4 [or OP = 1.2] [m]
0 0 0 | M1A1 | Find extension e [or OP ] at equilibrium position P
0 0 0
2 d2x/dt2 = – 40 (e + x) / 0.8 + 2g
0
or = + 40 (e – x) / 0.8 – 2g
0 | M1A1 | Use Newton’s law at general point (e.g. x below or above P )
0
(ignore LHS sign here only)
OR: 2 d2y/dt2 = – 40 (y – 0.8) / 0.8 + 2g
= – 50 y + 60 | (M1A1 | Use Newton’s law at general point in terms of y = OP
(ignore LHS sign here only)
Take x = y – 1.2 to give | M1A1) | Change variable to give standard form of SHM eqn
d2x/dt2 = – 25x | A1 | Hence SHM (A0 if wrong sign or LHS unclear)
(B1 only for stating SHM eqn. without proof)
T = 2π / √(25) = 2π/5 AG | A1 | Verify period T using T = 2π/ω with ω = √(25)
OP = 1.2 [m]
0 | B1 | State OP explicitly (may imply first M1 A1)
0
7
11A(ii) | 0.42 = 25 (a2 – 0.062) | M1A1 | Find amplitude a from v2 = ω2 (a2 – x2)
a = √(0.0064 + 0.0036) = 0.1 [m] | A1
3
11A(iii) | 40 e / 0.8 = (2 + M) g, [e = 0.4 + 0.2 M]
1 1
or 40(e – e ) / 0.8 = Mg [e – e = 0.2 M]
1 0 1 0 | M1A1 | Find extension e [or OP ] at first equilibrium position P
1 1 1
or equate additional extension to M by Hooke’s Law
e – e = a , M = a/0.2 = 0.5
1 0 | M1A1 | Find M by relating e , e and a
0 1
4
Question | Answer | Marks | Guidance
11B(i) | H : µ = µ , H : µ > µ (or in terms of µ , µ )
0 x y 1 x y A B | B1 | State hypotheses (B0 forx …)
s 2 = (14.1775 – 10.562/8) / 7 = 0.03404 and
x
s 2 = (15.894 – 12.392/10) / 9 = 0.06031 (to 3 s.f.)
y | M1A1 | Estimate both population variances
(allow biased here: 0.02979 and 0.05428)
s2 = (7 s 2 + 9 s 2) / 16
x y
or (14.1775 – 10.562/8 + 15.894 – 12.392/10) / 16
= 0.78 109 / 16 or 0.04882 or 0.220952 (to 3 s.f.) | M1A1 | Find pooled estimate of common variance
(M1 A1 for s 2 and s 2 may be implied here)
x y
t = 1.337 (to 3 s.f.)
16. 0.9 | *B1 | State or use correct tabular t value
t = (1.32 – 1.239) / s√(1/10 + 1/8) = 0.773 | M1A1 | Calculate value of t (or –t)
(or can comparey –x = 0.081 with 0.140)
t < tabular value
so claim not justified or A’s not heavier than B’s (AEF) | B1 | Correct conclusion (FT on t, dep *B1)
SC: z = (1.32 – 1.239) / √(s 2/8 + s 2/10)
x y
= 0.081 / √(0.078) = 0.799 | (B1 | SC: Implicitly taking s 2, s 2 as unequal popln. variances
x y
(may also earn first B1 M1 A1)
z < 1.282 so claim is not justified (AEF) | B1) | Comparison with z and conclusion (FT on z; max 5/9)
0.9
9
11B(ii) | x = 1.28 and s2 = 0.294 / 7 [= 0.042 (or 0.2052)] | M1 | Find sample mean & estimate popn. var (allow M1 if 0.294 / 8)
t = (1.28 – p) / √(0.042/8) (AEF) | M1A1 | Find value of t
t > 1.415 (< is A0), p < 1.28 – 0.1025, p = 1.18
max | M1A1 | Find p by comparison with tabular value, here t
max 7. 0.9
5
The number of accidents, $x$, that occur each day on a motorway are recorded over a period of 40 days. The results are shown in the following table.

\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
Number of accidents & 0 & 1 & 2 & 3 & 4 & 5 & 6 & $\geqslant 7$ \\
\hline
Observed frequency & 3 & 5 & 8 & 10 & 5 & 7 & 2 & 0 \\
\hline
\end{tabular}

\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]
\item Show that the mean number of accidents each day is 2.95 and calculate the variance for this sample. Explain why these values suggest that a Poisson distribution might fit the data.
[3]

\item A Poisson distribution with mean 2.95, as found from the data, is used to calculate the expected frequencies, correct to 2 decimal places. The results are shown in the following table.

\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
Number of accidents & 0 & 1 & 2 & 3 & 4 & 5 & 6 & $\geqslant 7$ \\
\hline
Observed frequency & 3 & 5 & 8 & 10 & 5 & 7 & 2 & 0 \\
\hline
Expected frequency & 2.09 & 6.18 & 9.11 & 8.96 & 6.61 & 3.90 & 1.92 & 1.23 \\
\hline
\end{tabular}

Show how the expected frequency of 6.61 for $x = 4$ is obtained.
[2]

\item Test at the 5% significance level the goodness of fit of this Poisson distribution to the data.
[7]
\end{enumerate]

\hfill \mbox{\textit{CAIE FP2 2018 Q10 [12]}}