Pre-U Pre-U 9795/2 2018 June — Question 10 6 marks

Exam BoardPre-U
ModulePre-U 9795/2 (Pre-U Further Mathematics Paper 2)
Year2018
SessionJune
Marks6
TopicSimple Harmonic Motion
TypeSmall oscillations: simple pendulum (particle on string)
DifficultyStandard +0.8 This is a multi-part pendulum question requiring derivation of SHM approximation, application of SHM formulas, energy methods, and error analysis. While the small-angle approximation is standard A-level Further Maths content, the comparison between approximate and exact methods with percentage error calculation elevates it above routine exercises. The angles (0.3, 0.2 rad) are deliberately chosen to test understanding of approximation validity, requiring more sophisticated reasoning than typical textbook problems.
Spec6.02i Conservation of energy: mechanical energy principle6.05e Radial/tangential acceleration

10 A particle \(P\) is attached to one end of a light inextensible string of length 1.4 m . The other end of the string is fixed to the ceiling at \(C\). The angle between \(C P\) and the vertical is \(\theta\) radians. The particle is held with the string taut with \(\theta = 0.3\) and is then released.
  1. (a) Show that the motion of the system is approximately simple harmonic, and state its period.
    (b) Hence find an approximation for the speed of \(P\) when \(\theta = 0.2\).
  2. Find the speed of \(P\) when \(\theta = 0.2\) using an energy method, and hence find the percentage error in the answer to part (i) (b).

Question 10(i)(a)
- \(-mg\sin\theta = mr\ddot{\theta}\) cwo M1 NII tangentially. Ignore radial
- \(\ddot{\theta} = -\frac{g}{r}\sin\theta \approx -\frac{g}{r}\theta\) so approx. SHM A2 A1 for \(\ddot{\theta}\) correct including signs; A1 for \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\) and stating SHM
- Period \(2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)\) (seconds) B1 awrt 2.35 or \(\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}\)
Alternative 1 (Hor & Vert):
- \(-T\sin\theta = ma\cos\theta\) and M1 NII (\(\uparrow\)) and (\(\leftrightarrow\))
- \(T\cos\theta - mg\sin\theta = ma\sin\theta\) cwo A1 both fully correct
- \(\ddot{\theta} = -\frac{g}{r}\sin\theta \approx -\frac{g}{r}\theta\) so approx. SHM A1 eliminating \(T\) and using \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\) and \(a = r\ddot{\theta}\) and stating SHM
- Period \(2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)\) (seconds) B1 awrt 2.35 or \(\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}\)
Alternative 2 (\(x\)):
- \(-mg\sin\theta = m\ddot{x}\) cwo M1 NII tangentially. Ignore radial
- \(\ddot{x} = -g\sin\theta \approx -g\theta = -\frac{g}{r}x\) so approx. SHM A2 A1 for \(\ddot{x}\) correct including signs; A1 for using \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\) and \(x = r\theta\) (or just \(x \approx r\sin\theta\)) and stating SHM
- Period \(2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)\) (seconds) B1 awrt 2.35 or \(\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}\)
Alternative 3 (energy):
- \(\frac{1}{2}mv^2 + mgr - mgr\cos\theta = \text{const}\) M1 adding KE and PE (condone sign errors)
- \(v = r\dot{\theta}\) (or this and \(\dot{v} = r\ddot{\theta}\)) used to derive DE M1 eliminating \(v\) (and/or \(\dot{v}\))
- \(mr^2\dot{\theta}\ddot{\theta} + mgr\sin\theta\dot{\theta} = 0 \Rightarrow \ddot{\theta} + \frac{g}{r}\theta \approx 0\) so approx. SHM A1 differentiating implicitly, using \(\sin\theta \approx \theta\) and rearranging and stating SHM
- Period \(2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)\) (seconds) B1 awrt 2.35 or \(\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}\)
Question 10(i)(b)
- \(\dot{\theta}^2 = \omega^2(\theta_0^2 - \theta^2)\) M1 SHM energy equation in terms of \(\theta\) and \(\dot{\theta}\) used
- \(= \frac{10}{1.4}(0.3^2 - 0.2^2)\) A1 FT for correct equation with their \(\omega\)
- \(v = r\dot{\theta} = 1.4\times0.5976...\) M1 using \(v = r\dot{\theta}\)
- \(v = 0.836(66...)\) or \(\sqrt{70}/10\) or awrt 0.837 A1 converting to \(v\)
Alternative 1 (\(x\)):
- \(v^2 = \omega^2(a^2 - x^2)\) M1 SHM energy equation in terms of \(v\) and \(x\) used
- \(x = 1.4\theta\) soi M1 either \(x = 0.28\) or \(a = 0.42\)
- \(v^2 = \frac{10}{1.4}(0.42^2 - 0.28^2)\) A1 FT for correct equation with their \(\omega\)
- \(v = 0.836(66...)\) or \(\sqrt{70}/10\) or awrt 0.837 A1
Alternative 2 (\(\theta\) solution):
- Solution to SHM equation is \(\theta = A\cos\omega t\) (\(+B\sin\omega t\)) so initial conditions \(\Rightarrow \theta = 0.3\cos\omega t\) M1 particular solution, their \(\omega\)
- Substituting \(\omega t = \cos^{-1}\frac{2}{3}\) into \(\dot{\theta} = \pm0.3\omega\sin\omega t\) M1 Award if \(\sin^{-1}\) into \(\pm0.3\omega\cos\omega t\)
- \(v = r\dot{\theta} = 1.4\times0.5976...\) M1 using \(v = r\dot{\theta}\)
- \(v = 0.836(66...)\) or \(\sqrt{70}/10\) or awrt 0.837 A1 converting to \(v\) (must be +ve)
Alternative 3 (\(x\) solution):
- Gen sol to SHM eqn is \(x = A\cos\omega t\) (\(+B\sin\omega t\)) M1
- so initial conditions \(\Rightarrow x = 0.42\cos\omega t\) A1 using \(t=0 \Rightarrow\) both \(v=0\) and \(x = 1.4\times0.3\)
- Substituting \(\omega t = \cos^{-1}\frac{2}{3}\) into \(\dot{x} = \pm0.42\omega\sin\omega t\) M1 Award if \(\sin^{-1}\) in \(\pm0.42\omega\cos\omega t\)
- \(v = 0.836(66...)\) or \(\sqrt{70}/10\) or awrt 0.837 A1 must be +ve
Question 10(ii)
- KE gained = PE lost M1
- \(\frac{1}{2}mv^2 = mg(1.4\cos0.2 - 1.4\cos0.3)\) A1 correct equation
- \([v^2 = 0.692]\) \(v = 0.832(13)\) A1 awrt 0.832
- % difference \(0.544\%\) A1 awrt 0.544 (could be from correct calculations of \(\dot{\theta}\))
**Question 10(i)(a)**

- $-mg\sin\theta = mr\ddot{\theta}$ cwo **M1** NII tangentially. Ignore radial

- $\ddot{\theta} = -\frac{g}{r}\sin\theta \approx -\frac{g}{r}\theta$ so approx. SHM **A2** **A1** for $\ddot{\theta}$ correct including signs; **A1** for $\sin\theta \approx \theta$ and stating SHM

- Period $2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)$ (seconds) **B1** awrt 2.35 or $\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}$

**Alternative 1 (Hor & Vert):**

- $-T\sin\theta = ma\cos\theta$ and **M1** NII ($\uparrow$) and ($\leftrightarrow$)

- $T\cos\theta - mg\sin\theta = ma\sin\theta$ cwo **A1** both fully correct

- $\ddot{\theta} = -\frac{g}{r}\sin\theta \approx -\frac{g}{r}\theta$ so approx. SHM **A1** eliminating $T$ and using $\sin\theta \approx \theta$ and $a = r\ddot{\theta}$ and stating SHM

- Period $2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)$ (seconds) **B1** awrt 2.35 or $\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}$

**Alternative 2 ($x$):**

- $-mg\sin\theta = m\ddot{x}$ cwo **M1** NII tangentially. Ignore radial

- $\ddot{x} = -g\sin\theta \approx -g\theta = -\frac{g}{r}x$ so approx. SHM **A2** **A1** for $\ddot{x}$ correct including signs; **A1** for using $\sin\theta \approx \theta$ and $x = r\theta$ (or just $x \approx r\sin\theta$) and stating SHM

- Period $2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)$ (seconds) **B1** awrt 2.35 or $\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}$

**Alternative 3 (energy):**

- $\frac{1}{2}mv^2 + mgr - mgr\cos\theta = \text{const}$ **M1** adding KE and PE (condone sign errors)

- $v = r\dot{\theta}$ (or this and $\dot{v} = r\ddot{\theta}$) used to derive DE **M1** eliminating $v$ (and/or $\dot{v}$)

- $mr^2\dot{\theta}\ddot{\theta} + mgr\sin\theta\dot{\theta} = 0 \Rightarrow \ddot{\theta} + \frac{g}{r}\theta \approx 0$ so approx. SHM **A1** differentiating implicitly, using $\sin\theta \approx \theta$ and rearranging and stating SHM

- Period $2\pi \div \omega = 2.35(095)$ (seconds) **B1** awrt 2.35 or $\frac{1}{5}\pi\sqrt{14}$

**Question 10(i)(b)**

- $\dot{\theta}^2 = \omega^2(\theta_0^2 - \theta^2)$ **M1** SHM energy equation in terms of $\theta$ and $\dot{\theta}$ used

- $= \frac{10}{1.4}(0.3^2 - 0.2^2)$ **A1** FT for correct equation with their $\omega$

- $v = r\dot{\theta} = 1.4\times0.5976...$ **M1** using $v = r\dot{\theta}$

- $v = 0.836(66...)$ or $\sqrt{70}/10$ or awrt 0.837 **A1** converting to $v$

**Alternative 1 ($x$):**

- $v^2 = \omega^2(a^2 - x^2)$ **M1** SHM energy equation in terms of $v$ and $x$ used

- $x = 1.4\theta$ soi **M1** either $x = 0.28$ or $a = 0.42$

- $v^2 = \frac{10}{1.4}(0.42^2 - 0.28^2)$ **A1** FT for correct equation with their $\omega$

- $v = 0.836(66...)$ or $\sqrt{70}/10$ or awrt 0.837 **A1**

**Alternative 2 ($\theta$ solution):**

- Solution to SHM equation is $\theta = A\cos\omega t$ ($+B\sin\omega t$) so initial conditions $\Rightarrow \theta = 0.3\cos\omega t$ **M1** particular solution, their $\omega$

- Substituting $\omega t = \cos^{-1}\frac{2}{3}$ into $\dot{\theta} = \pm0.3\omega\sin\omega t$ **M1** Award if $\sin^{-1}$ into $\pm0.3\omega\cos\omega t$

- $v = r\dot{\theta} = 1.4\times0.5976...$ **M1** using $v = r\dot{\theta}$

- $v = 0.836(66...)$ or $\sqrt{70}/10$ or awrt 0.837 **A1** converting to $v$ (must be +ve)

**Alternative 3 ($x$ solution):**

- Gen sol to SHM eqn is $x = A\cos\omega t$ ($+B\sin\omega t$) **M1**

- so initial conditions $\Rightarrow x = 0.42\cos\omega t$ **A1** using $t=0 \Rightarrow$ both $v=0$ and $x = 1.4\times0.3$

- Substituting $\omega t = \cos^{-1}\frac{2}{3}$ into $\dot{x} = \pm0.42\omega\sin\omega t$ **M1** Award if $\sin^{-1}$ in $\pm0.42\omega\cos\omega t$

- $v = 0.836(66...)$ or $\sqrt{70}/10$ or awrt 0.837 **A1** must be +ve

**Question 10(ii)**

- KE gained = PE lost **M1**

- $\frac{1}{2}mv^2 = mg(1.4\cos0.2 - 1.4\cos0.3)$ **A1** correct equation

- $[v^2 = 0.692]$ $v = 0.832(13)$ **A1** awrt 0.832

- % difference $0.544\%$ **A1** awrt 0.544 (could be from correct calculations of $\dot{\theta}$)
10 A particle $P$ is attached to one end of a light inextensible string of length 1.4 m . The other end of the string is fixed to the ceiling at $C$. The angle between $C P$ and the vertical is $\theta$ radians. The particle is held with the string taut with $\theta = 0.3$ and is then released.
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]
\item (a) Show that the motion of the system is approximately simple harmonic, and state its period.\\
(b) Hence find an approximation for the speed of $P$ when $\theta = 0.2$.
\item Find the speed of $P$ when $\theta = 0.2$ using an energy method, and hence find the percentage error in the answer to part (i) (b).
\end{enumerate}

\hfill \mbox{\textit{Pre-U Pre-U 9795/2 2018 Q10 [6]}}