OCR MEI Further Mechanics A AS 2020 November — Question 2

Exam BoardOCR MEI
ModuleFurther Mechanics A AS (Further Mechanics A AS)
Year2020
SessionNovember
TopicDimensional Analysis

2 George is investigating the time it takes for a ball to reach a certain height when projected vertically upwards. George believes that the time, \(t\), for the ball to reach a certain height, \(h\), depends on
  • the ball's mass \(m\),
  • the projection speed \(u\), and
  • the height \(h\).
George suggests the following formula to model this situation
\(t = k m ^ { \alpha } u ^ { \beta } h ^ { \gamma }\),
where \(k\) is a dimensionless constant.
  1. Use dimensional analysis to show that \(t = \frac { k h } { u }\).
  2. Hence explain why George’s formula is unrealistic. Mandy argues that any model of this situation must consider the acceleration due to gravity, \(g\). She suggests the alternative formula
    \(t = \frac { u - \sqrt { u ^ { 2 } + g h } } { g }\).
  3. Show that Mandy's formula is dimensionally consistent.
  4. Explain why Mandy’s formula is incorrect.