| Exam Board | OCR MEI |
|---|---|
| Module | S1 (Statistics 1) |
| Year | 2016 |
| Session | June |
| Marks | 18 |
| Paper | Download PDF ↗ |
| Mark scheme | Download PDF ↗ |
| Topic | Hypothesis test of binomial distributions |
| Type | Expected value and most likely value |
| Difficulty | Moderate -0.3 This is a standard hypothesis testing question covering routine binomial probability calculations and basic test setup. Part (i) involves direct application of binomial formulas, part (ii) is standard hypothesis formulation, part (iii) requires understanding of significance levels and critical regions, and part (iv) is a straightforward one-tailed test with probabilities provided. While multi-part, each component is textbook-standard with no novel problem-solving required, making it slightly easier than average. |
| Spec | 2.04b Binomial distribution: as model B(n,p)2.04c Calculate binomial probabilities2.05a Hypothesis testing language: null, alternative, p-value, significance2.05b Hypothesis test for binomial proportion2.05c Significance levels: one-tail and two-tail |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| \(P(X=3) = 0.25^4\times0.75^{16}\binom{20}{4}\times0.25^4\times0.75^{16} = 0.1423\) | M1 | For \(0.1^3\times0.9^{13}\) |
| M1 | For \(\binom{16}{3}\times p^3\times q^{13}\) | |
| A1 [3] | CAO | |
| Or from tables: \(P(X\leq3) - P(X\leq2) = 0.9316 - 0.7892 = 0.1424\) | M2, A1 | For \(0.9316 - 0.7892\) |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| \(P(X\geq3) = 1 - P(X\leq2) = 1 - 0.7892 = 0.2108\) | M1 | For 0.7892 |
| A1 [2] | CAO; if calculating \(P(X=0)+P(X=1)+P(X=2)\) allow M1 for 0.79 or better |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Expected number \(= 16\times0.1 = 1.6\) | B1 [1] | Do not allow final answer of 1 or 2 even if correct 1.6 given earlier |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Let \(p\) = probability of a randomly chosen person using 1234 as their PIN (in the population) | B1 | For definition of \(p\) in context; do NOT allow number in place of probability |
| \(H_0: p = 0.1\) | B1 | For \(H_0\) |
| \(H_1: p < 0.1\) | B1 | |
| The alternative hypothesis has this form as the advertising campaign aims to reduce the proportion of the population who use 1234 as their PIN | B1 [4] | Dep on \(< 0.1\) used in \(H_1\); do not allow just 'proportion will be lower' or similar |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| For \(n=20\), \(P(X\leq0) = 0.1216\) | M1* | For sight of 0.1216; condone \(P(X=0)\) in place of \(P(X\leq0)\) |
| \(0.1216 > 0.10\) | *M1dep | For \(> 0.10\) or \(> 10\%\); do NOT FT wrong \(H_1\) |
| So no point in carrying out the test as \(H_0\) could not be rejected (even if nobody in the sample uses 1234 as their PIN) oe | A1 [3] | or state 'There is no critical region' oe; for A1 need \(P(X\leq0)\) or \(P(X=0)\) somewhere |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest value of \(k\) is 13 | B1 [1] | Or 13% |
| Answer | Marks | Guidance |
|---|---|---|
| \(P(X\leq2) = 0.0530\) | B1 | For use of \(P(X\leq2)\) only |
| \(0.0530 > 0.05\) | M1 | For comparison of 0.0530 with 5% |
| So not significant. Do not reject \(H_0\) | A1* | |
| Conclude that there is not enough evidence to support the suggestion that the advertising campaign has been successful | *E1 dep [4] | Must include 'insufficient evidence to suggest that' or similar; allow 'accept \(H_0\)' or 'reject \(H_1\)' |
| Answer | Marks |
|---|---|
| Guidance | |
| Minimum needed for B1: \(p\) = probability of using 1234 | |
| Allow \(p = P(\text{using } 1234)\) | |
| Definition must include word *probability* (or *chance*, *proportion*, *percentage*, *likelihood*) — NOT *possibility*, *number*, or *amount* | |
| Preferably given as separate comment, but can appear at end of \(H_0\) if clearly stated as '\(p\) = the probability of using 1234' | |
| Do NOT allow '\(p\) = the probability of using 1234 is different' | |
| Allow \(p = 10\%\); allow only \(p\), \(\theta\), \(\pi\), or \(\rho\); allow any single symbol if defined (including \(x\)) | |
| Allow \(H_0 = p = 0.1\); Allow \(H_0 : p = \frac{1}{10}\) | |
| Allow NH and AH in place of \(H_0\) and \(H_1\) | |
| Do not allow \(H_0 : P(X = x) = 0.1\) | |
| Do not allow \(H_0: {=}0.1,\ {=}10\%,\ P(0.1),\ p(x){=}0.1,\ x{=}0.1\) (unless \(x\) correctly defined as a probability) | |
| Do not allow \(H_0\) and \(H_1\) reversed | |
| For hypotheses given in words: allow Maximum B0B1B1 | |
| Hypotheses in words must include *probability* (or *chance*, *proportion*, *percentage*) and the figure \(0.1\) | |
| e.g. \(H_0: P(\text{using } 1234) = 0.1,\ H_1: P(\text{using } 1234) < 0.1\) gets B0B1B1 |
# Question 7:
## Part (i)(A)
$X\sim B(16, 0.1)$
$P(X=3) = 0.25^4\times0.75^{16}\binom{20}{4}\times0.25^4\times0.75^{16} = 0.1423$ | M1 | For $0.1^3\times0.9^{13}$
| M1 | For $\binom{16}{3}\times p^3\times q^{13}$
| A1 [3] | CAO
Or from tables: $P(X\leq3) - P(X\leq2) = 0.9316 - 0.7892 = 0.1424$ | M2, A1 | For $0.9316 - 0.7892$
---
## Part (i)(B)
$P(X\geq3) = 1 - P(X\leq2) = 1 - 0.7892 = 0.2108$ | M1 | For 0.7892
| A1 [2] | CAO; if calculating $P(X=0)+P(X=1)+P(X=2)$ allow M1 for 0.79 or better
---
## Part (i)(C)
Expected number $= 16\times0.1 = 1.6$ | B1 [1] | Do not allow final answer of 1 or 2 even if correct 1.6 given earlier
---
## Part (ii)
Let $p$ = probability of a randomly chosen person using 1234 as their PIN (in the population) | B1 | For definition of $p$ in context; do NOT allow number in place of probability
$H_0: p = 0.1$ | B1 | For $H_0$
$H_1: p < 0.1$ | B1 |
The alternative hypothesis has this form as the advertising campaign aims to reduce the proportion of the population who use 1234 as their PIN | B1 [4] | Dep on $< 0.1$ used in $H_1$; do not allow just 'proportion will be lower' or similar
---
## Part (iii)(A)
For $n=20$, $P(X\leq0) = 0.1216$ | M1* | For sight of 0.1216; condone $P(X=0)$ in place of $P(X\leq0)$
$0.1216 > 0.10$ | *M1dep | For $> 0.10$ or $> 10\%$; do NOT FT wrong $H_1$
So no point in carrying out the test as $H_0$ could not be rejected (even if nobody in the sample uses 1234 as their PIN) oe | A1 [3] | or state 'There is no critical region' oe; for A1 need $P(X\leq0)$ or $P(X=0)$ somewhere
---
## Part (iii)(B)
Lowest value of $k$ is 13 | B1 [1] | Or 13%
---
## Part (iv)
$P(X\leq2) = 0.0530$ | B1 | For use of $P(X\leq2)$ only
$0.0530 > 0.05$ | M1 | For comparison of 0.0530 with 5%
So not significant. Do not reject $H_0$ | A1* |
Conclude that there is not enough evidence to support the suggestion that the advertising campaign has been successful | *E1 dep [4] | Must include 'insufficient evidence to suggest that' or similar; allow 'accept $H_0$' or 'reject $H_1$'
## Additional Notes: Q7 Part (ii) — Hypotheses for Binomial Test
---
**Definitions and Allowances for p (B1):**
| Guidance |
|----------|
| Minimum needed for B1: $p$ = probability of using 1234 |
| Allow $p = P(\text{using } 1234)$ |
| Definition must include word *probability* (or *chance*, *proportion*, *percentage*, *likelihood*) — NOT *possibility*, *number*, or *amount* |
| Preferably given as separate comment, but can appear at end of $H_0$ if clearly stated as '$p$ = the probability of using 1234' |
| Do NOT allow '$p$ = the probability of using 1234 is different' |
| Allow $p = 10\%$; allow only $p$, $\theta$, $\pi$, or $\rho$; allow any single symbol **if defined** (including $x$) |
| Allow $H_0 = p = 0.1$; Allow $H_0 : p = \frac{1}{10}$ |
| Allow NH and AH in place of $H_0$ and $H_1$ |
| Do not allow $H_0 : P(X = x) = 0.1$ |
| Do not allow $H_0: {=}0.1,\ {=}10\%,\ P(0.1),\ p(x){=}0.1,\ x{=}0.1$ (unless $x$ correctly defined as a probability) |
| Do not allow $H_0$ and $H_1$ reversed |
| For hypotheses given in words: allow Maximum **B0B1B1** |
| Hypotheses in words must include *probability* (or *chance*, *proportion*, *percentage*) and the figure $0.1$ |
| e.g. $H_0: P(\text{using } 1234) = 0.1,\ H_1: P(\text{using } 1234) < 0.1$ gets **B0B1B1** |
7 To withdraw money from a cash machine, the user has to enter a 4-digit PIN (personal identification number). There are several thousand possible 4-digit PINs, but a survey found that $10 \%$ of cash machine users use the PIN '1234'.
\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]
\item 16 cash machine users are selected at random.\\
(A) Find the probability that exactly 3 of them use 1234 as their PIN.\\
(B) Find the probability that at least 3 of them use 1234 as their PIN.\\
(C) Find the expected number of them who use 1234 as their PIN.
An advertising campaign aims to reduce the number of people who use 1234 as their PIN. A hypothesis test is to be carried out to investigate whether the advertising campaign has been successful.
\item Write down suitable null and alternative hypotheses for the test. Give a reason for your choice of alternative hypothesis.
\item A random sample of 20 cash machine users is selected.\\
(A) Explain why the test could not be carried out at the $10 \%$ significance level.\\
(B) The test is to be carried out at the $k \%$ significance level. State the lowest integer value of $k$ for which the test could result in the rejection of the null hypothesis.
\item A new random sample of 60 cash machine users is selected. It is found that 2 of them use 1234 as their PIN. You are given that, if $X \sim \mathrm {~B} ( 60,0.1 )$, then (to 4 decimal places)
$$\mathrm { P } ( X = 2 ) = 0.0393 , \quad \mathrm { P } ( X < 2 ) = 0.0138 , \quad \mathrm { P } ( X \leqslant 2 ) = 0.0530 .$$
Using the same hypotheses as in part (ii), carry out the test at the $5 \%$ significance level.
\section*{END OF QUESTION PAPER}
\end{enumerate}
\hfill \mbox{\textit{OCR MEI S1 2016 Q7 [18]}}