OCR MEI S2 2012 January — Question 3 19 marks

Exam BoardOCR MEI
ModuleS2 (Statistics 2)
Year2012
SessionJanuary
Marks19
PaperDownload PDF ↗
Mark schemeDownload PDF ↗
TopicApproximating Binomial to Normal Distribution
TypeNormal distribution probability then binomial/normal approximation on sample
DifficultyStandard +0.3 This is a multi-part question covering standard S2 topics: basic normal probability calculation, normal approximation to binomial, inverse normal problem, and a routine hypothesis test. All parts use textbook methods with no novel insight required. Part (ii) requires recognizing the binomial setup and applying continuity correction, which is slightly above average for S2, but overall this is a straightforward application question typical of statistics modules.
Spec2.04e Normal distribution: as model N(mu, sigma^2)2.04f Find normal probabilities: Z transformation5.04b Linear combinations: of normal distributions5.05c Hypothesis test: normal distribution for population mean

3 The lifetime of a particular type of light bulb is \(X\) hours, where \(X\) is Normally distributed with mean 1100 and variance 2000.
  1. Find \(\mathrm { P } ( 1100 < X < 1200 )\).
  2. Use a suitable approximating distribution to find the probability that, in a random sample of 100 of these light bulbs, no more than 40 have a lifetime between 1100 and 1200 hours.
  3. A factory has a large number of these light bulbs installed. As soon as \(1 \%\) of the bulbs have come to the end of their lifetimes, it is company policy to replace all of the bulbs. After how many hours should the bulbs need to be replaced?
  4. The bulbs are to be replaced by low-energy bulbs. The lifetime of these bulbs is Normally distributed and the mean is claimed by the manufacturer to be 7000 hours. The standard deviation is known to be 100 hours. A random sample of 25 low-energy bulbs is selected. Their mean lifetime is found to be 6972 hours. Carry out a 2 -tail test at the \(10 \%\) level to investigate the claim.
    [0pt] [Question 4 is printed overleaf.]

(i)
Answer:
\[P(1100 < X < 1200) = P\left(\frac{1100-1100}{\sqrt{2000}} < Z < \frac{1200-1100}{\sqrt{2000}}\right)\]
\[= P(0 < Z < 2.236) = \Phi(2.236) - 0.5 = 0.9873 - 0.5 = 0.4873\]
AnswerMarks Guidance
Marks: M1M1 A1
Guidance:
- M1 for for standardising
- M0 if 'continuity correction' applied
- M1 for for correct structure
- A1 CAO do not allow 0.4871, 0.48713, 0.48745 or 0.4875
(ii)
Answer: Use Normal approx with
\[\mu = np = 100 \times 0.4873 = 48.73\]
\[\sigma^2 = npq = 100 \times 0.4873 \times 0.5127 = 24.98\]
\[P(X \leq 40) = P\left(Z \leq \frac{40.5-48.73}{\sqrt{24.98}}\right)\]
\[= P(Z \leq -1.647) = 1 - \Phi(1.647) = 1 - 0.9502 = 0.0498\]
AnswerMarks Guidance
Marks: B1B1 B1
Guidance:
- B1 B1 for \(\mu\) & \(\sigma^2\) It their answer to part (i) provided that a normal approximation is appropriate from their part (i).
- B1 for continuity correction 40.5
- M1 correct structure using appropriate Normal approximation
- CAO 3s.f.
- NOTE Using B(100, 0.4873) gives 0.0494. which gets 0/5
- SC If p small enough to justify a Poisson approximation, e.g. 0.05, then B1 for Poisson used, B1 ft for parameter, M1 for structure,M1 attempt at summation, A0
(iii)
Answer: From tables \(\Phi^{-1}(0.01) = -2.326\)
\[\frac{k-1100}{\sqrt{2000}} = -2.326\]
\[k = 1100 - 2.326 \times \sqrt{2000}\]
\[k = 996\]
AnswerMarks Guidance
Marks: B1M1 A1
Guidance:
- B1 ±2.326 seen
- M1 correct equation as seen or equivalent
- CAO Allow 996.0
Question 3(iv)
Answer:
\[H_0: \mu = 7000;\]
\[H_1: \mu \neq 7000\]
Where \(\mu\) denotes the population mean lifetime of low energy bulbs
\[\text{Test statistic} = \frac{6972 - 7000}{100/\sqrt{25}} = \frac{-28}{20} = -1.4\]
Lower 10% level 2 tailed critical value of z = − 1.645
\(-1.4 > -1.645\) so not significant.
There is not sufficient evidence to reject \(H_0\)
There is insufficient evidence to conclude that the manufacturer is wrong.
AnswerMarks Guidance
Marks: B1B1 B1
Guidance:
- B1 For use of 7000 in hypotheses
- B1 For correct hypotheses given in terms of \(\mu\) (not p or x, etc. unless letter used is clearly defined as population mean.) If hypotheses are reversed lose second B1 and final A1
- B1 for definition of \(\mu\).
- M1 calculation of test statistic with a divisor of \(100/\sqrt{25}\). Condone numerator reversed.
- A1 CAO for − 1.4. Allow +1.4 for A1 only if this is later compared with +1.645
- B1 For −1.645. Must be negative unless it is clear that absolute values are being used. NB: FT a 1-tail test (c.v. = −1.282)
- M1 for a sensible comparison leading to a conclusion.
- A1 For correct conclusion in context. FT only their test statistic if c.v. correct and both M marks earned.
Critical Value Method
7000 − 1.645 × 100 ÷ √25 gets M1B1 = 6967.1 gets A1
6972 > 6967.1 gets M1for sensible comparison A1 still available for correct conclusion in words & context
Confidence Interval Method
CI centred on 6972 ± or − 1.645 × 100 ÷ √25 gets M1 B1 = (6939.1, 7004.9) gets A1
contains 7000 gets M1 A1 still available for correct conclusion in words & context
Probability Method
Finding P(sample mean < 6972) = 0.0808 gets M1 A1 B1
0.0808 > 0.05 gets M1 for a sensible comparison if a conclusion is made.
0.0808 < 0.10 gets M1 A0 unless using one-tailed test A1 still available for correct (one-tailed) conclusion in words & context.
Condone P(sample mean > 6972) = 0.9192 for M1 but only allow A1 B1 if later compared with 0.95, at which point the final M1and A1 are still available
One-tailed test
Max B1 B0 B1 M1 A1 B1 (for cv = -1.282) M1 A0
## (i)

**Answer:**
$$P(1100 < X < 1200) = P\left(\frac{1100-1100}{\sqrt{2000}} < Z < \frac{1200-1100}{\sqrt{2000}}\right)$$

$$= P(0 < Z < 2.236) = \Phi(2.236) - 0.5 = 0.9873 - 0.5 = 0.4873$$

**Marks:** M1 | M1 | A1

**Guidance:**
- M1 for for standardising
- M0 if 'continuity correction' applied
- M1 for for correct structure
- A1 CAO do not allow 0.4871, 0.48713, 0.48745 or 0.4875

---

## (ii)

**Answer:** Use Normal approx with

$$\mu = np = 100 \times 0.4873 = 48.73$$

$$\sigma^2 = npq = 100 \times 0.4873 \times 0.5127 = 24.98$$

$$P(X \leq 40) = P\left(Z \leq \frac{40.5-48.73}{\sqrt{24.98}}\right)$$

$$= P(Z \leq -1.647) = 1 - \Phi(1.647) = 1 - 0.9502 = 0.0498$$

**Marks:** B1 | B1 | B1 | M1 | A1

**Guidance:**
- B1 B1 for $\mu$ & $\sigma^2$ It their answer to part (i) provided that a normal approximation is appropriate from their part (i).
- B1 for continuity correction 40.5
- M1 correct structure using appropriate Normal approximation
- CAO 3s.f.
- NOTE Using B(100, 0.4873) gives 0.0494. which gets 0/5
- SC If p small enough to justify a Poisson approximation, e.g. 0.05, then B1 for Poisson used, B1 ft for parameter, M1 for structure,M1 attempt at summation, A0

---

## (iii)

**Answer:** From tables $\Phi^{-1}(0.01) = -2.326$

$$\frac{k-1100}{\sqrt{2000}} = -2.326$$

$$k = 1100 - 2.326 \times \sqrt{2000}$$
$$k = 996$$

**Marks:** B1 | M1 | A1

**Guidance:**
- B1 ±2.326 seen
- M1 correct equation as seen or equivalent
- CAO Allow 996.0

---

# Question 3(iv)

**Answer:**
$$H_0: \mu = 7000;$$
$$H_1: \mu \neq 7000$$

Where $\mu$ denotes the population mean lifetime of low energy bulbs

$$\text{Test statistic} = \frac{6972 - 7000}{100/\sqrt{25}} = \frac{-28}{20} = -1.4$$

Lower 10% level 2 tailed critical value of z = − 1.645

$-1.4 > -1.645$ so not significant.
There is not sufficient evidence to reject $H_0$
There is insufficient evidence to conclude that the manufacturer is wrong.

**Marks:** B1 | B1 | B1 | M1 | A1 | M1 | A1 | [8]

**Guidance:**
- B1 For use of 7000 in hypotheses
- B1 For correct hypotheses given in terms of $\mu$ (not p or x, etc. unless letter used is clearly defined as population mean.) If hypotheses are reversed lose second B1 and final A1
- B1 for definition of $\mu$.
- M1 calculation of test statistic with a divisor of $100/\sqrt{25}$. Condone numerator reversed.
- A1 CAO for − 1.4. Allow +1.4 for A1 only if this is later compared with +1.645
- B1 For −1.645. Must be negative unless it is clear that absolute values are being used. NB: FT a 1-tail test (c.v. = −1.282)
- M1 for a sensible comparison leading to a conclusion.
- A1 For correct conclusion in context. **FT only their test statistic if c.v. correct and both M marks earned.**

**Critical Value Method**
7000 − 1.645 × 100 ÷ √25 gets M1B1 = 6967.1 gets A1
6972 > 6967.1 gets M1for sensible comparison A1 still available for correct conclusion in words & context

**Confidence Interval Method**
CI centred on 6972 ± or − 1.645 × 100 ÷ √25 gets M1 B1 = (6939.1, 7004.9) gets A1
contains 7000 gets M1 A1 still available for correct conclusion in words & context

**Probability Method**
Finding P(sample mean < 6972) = 0.0808 gets M1 A1 B1
0.0808 > 0.05 gets M1 for a sensible comparison if a conclusion is made.
0.0808 < 0.10 gets M1 A0 unless using one-tailed test A1 still available for correct (one-tailed) conclusion in words & context.
Condone P(sample mean > 6972) = 0.9192 for M1 but only allow A1 B1 if later compared with 0.95, at which point the final M1and A1 are still available

**One-tailed test**
Max B1 B0 B1 M1 A1 B1 (for cv = -1.282) M1 A0

---
3 The lifetime of a particular type of light bulb is $X$ hours, where $X$ is Normally distributed with mean 1100 and variance 2000.\\
(i) Find $\mathrm { P } ( 1100 < X < 1200 )$.\\
(ii) Use a suitable approximating distribution to find the probability that, in a random sample of 100 of these light bulbs, no more than 40 have a lifetime between 1100 and 1200 hours.\\
(iii) A factory has a large number of these light bulbs installed. As soon as $1 \%$ of the bulbs have come to the end of their lifetimes, it is company policy to replace all of the bulbs. After how many hours should the bulbs need to be replaced?\\
(iv) The bulbs are to be replaced by low-energy bulbs. The lifetime of these bulbs is Normally distributed and the mean is claimed by the manufacturer to be 7000 hours. The standard deviation is known to be 100 hours. A random sample of 25 low-energy bulbs is selected. Their mean lifetime is found to be 6972 hours. Carry out a 2 -tail test at the $10 \%$ level to investigate the claim.\\[0pt]
[Question 4 is printed overleaf.]

\hfill \mbox{\textit{OCR MEI S2 2012 Q3 [19]}}